When quarterback Arch Manning committed to the Texas Longhorns in the summer of 2022, it came as a bit of a surprise to college football fans.

Manning committed to Texas over Alabama, Georgia, Clemson, LSU, and Virginia. 

At the time, Texas was coming off a 5-7 season in Steve Sarkisian's first year as the Longhorns' head coach. 

Alabama and Georgia were viewed by many as the favorites for Manning due to their annual standing as legitimate championship contenders (Alabama and Georgia had won the previous two national championships at the time of Manning's commitment). 

So why did Manning choose a program that had been mired in mediocrity over two established championship contenders? 

Manning recently pointed out that he liked the idea of bringing Texas "back". 

Another key reason, according to his brother Heid, is because it's easier to live a normal life while flying under-the-radar in Austin than it is in Tuscaloosa or Athens. 

"I remember him asking a lot of questions away from football," said Heid to 247Sports when asked about Arch's recruiting visits. "Like, nothing about NIL dollars or the NFL. He was asking, like, 'Am I going to be able to get away and maybe go somewhere where people don't recognize me as much?' And out of Athens, Tuscaloosa and Austin, I mean, it's easily Austin for that."

"Like, I think you can go to East Austin or South Congress, into more of those kind of quirky and Millennial-run neighborhoods, and he's not recognized as much. On campus, it's different. You get more people stopping you for pictures."

"But on his visits, he was asking, 'Is there anywhere I can lay low?' He loves his privacy, and he loves not being in the spotlight," continued Heid. "So I think that was a big part for him. I just think seeing Austin, he could see himself being happy when he was away from football. Texas has great education, and I think he just thought, 'Where would you want to be without football?' And it was Texas."

Arch is a unique case because he was already one of the most famous players in the sport before he had even signed with a college program. But in this new age of mega NIL deals for quarterback recruits, high school quarterbacks are in the spotlight from an early age more than ever before. 

And that can be extremely difficult for young quarterbacks. Just because a player is earning a big paycheck as a true freshman doesn't change that the player is 18 years old and still developing as a person (and as an athlete). The massive spotlight and not being able to walk around town with relative anonymity can be overwhelming. 

In football-crazed towns like Tuscaloosa and Athens, it's going to be virtually impossible to live a "normal life" as a five-star player. And for players who are serious about developing into the best player they can possibly be (instead of focusing on the NIL check), that's probably a concern. Most 18 year olds aren't capable of dealing with that kind of spotlight. And it can absolutely be a detriment to their development (the worst thing that a young collegiate athlete has to face are unreal expectations before they've even taken the field for a game). 

Arch is obviously dealing with those massive expectations while at Texas. But because he's in Austin, he can ignore social media (which he is reportedly adept at avoiding), step into downtown Austin, a town that isn't as football-crazed as Tuscaloosa, and escape those expectations by living his life simply as Arch and not at as "Arch Manning the future No. 1 overall selection in the NFL draft who everyone expects to lead Texas to a national championship". 

The ability to do that in Austin has to feel like a weight lifted off of Arch's shoulders. 

Alabama isn't going to have any issues landing elite talent over the next several years. And a lot of recruits are going to want the attention that comes with playing in Tuscaloosa. But when it comes to landing potentially generational players (elite talent, highly competitive, motivated, grounded, and smart enough to know that the glitz and glamour is a roadblock to success), we could see those guys choose a school like Texas where they can escape the 24/7 football environment as opposed to stepping into a town like Tuscaloosa where anonymity is essentially impossible. 

‘I hate Ohio State with everything in me’ – Georgia Bulldogs player doesn’t hold back on how he feels about the Buckeyes

He really doesn’t like Ohio State