NFL insider exposes why Aaron Rodgers and the Raiders could be a match made in hell

Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers is the white whale to the Raiders' fans Captain Ahab-level obsession. Rodgers represents what the Raiders want but can't have. And if the Raiders trade for Rodgers, it may not be all that it is theorized to be. At least, that is what one NFL insider believes. "I don't […]

Add as preferred source on Google
Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers (12) runs out on to the field as he is announced against the Detroit Lions during their football game Sunday, January 8, 2023, at Lambeau Field in Green Bay, Wis.

Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers is the white whale to the Raiders' fans Captain Ahab-level obsession.

Rodgers represents what the Raiders want but can't have. And if the Raiders trade for Rodgers, it may not be all that it is theorized to be. At least, that is what one NFL insider believes.

"I don't know that Josh McDaniels would be capable of adjusting his style to account for the delicate genius and not push him hard, not call him out," Mike Florio said when he joined "The Rich Eisen Show" on Thursday.

"You know the first thing McDaniels would say to him, Rich? 'Hey, Aaron. Here's what we have to do. Well, more importantly, here's what we have to stop doing. You can't go on the Pat McAfee Show every Tuesday. And You just can't do it. You can't go on and answer questions about the things we're doing here.' I mean, it's the Patriot way."

He added: "And these guys who leave [Bill] Belichick, they say they're going to be their own person. They don't realize how deeply ingrained the Patriot way has become in them. They think they're doing their own thing, and maybe it's a little modification, variation on the Patriot way, but they still, at their core, via osmosis, have picked up many of Belichick's tendencies…

"And Josh McDaniels knows what Tom Brady does, what he tolerates by way of hard coaching, or at least did, while he was with the Patriots until he'd had his lifetime limit of it. Aaron Rodgers is already at his lifetime limit of that. He doesn't want to be called out in meetings. He doesn't want the video to be shown of his bad decision and how he freelanced and even if the play worked out, he stepped away from the script. So again, they tell me Aaron Rodgers is really smart. If that's the case, I don't see him giving into the McDaniels system."

Rodgers has all the talent in the world, but he wouldn't match the culture that is being built in Las Vegas. It's easy to see how the Raiders could justify much of Rodgers' obscure behavior if it means winning. But it is also a tall task to go from Derek Carr — the consummate team-first quarterback — to Rodgers — the perfect example of a me-first playmaker.

Bringing Rodgers to Las Vegas may sound great theoretically. But when things get rocky during the season, Rodgers isn't someone who will take accountability the same way Carr could. That could hurt the Raiders more than it would help them.

Either way, Rodgers' fit with Las Vegas isn't as clear-cut as many make it out to be. It's a harsh reality, but it is a true one. Teams can buy talent. What they can't buy is a culture that produces winning. Las Vegas trading for Rodgers could be likened to a deal with the devil.

It would be a match made in hell.

Related Las Vegas Raiders reading

"Raiders GM explains why the team couldn't win close games." 

"The cruel QB reality the Raiders are heading towards." 

"Another potential QB option for the Raiders." 

Feature image via Dan Powers/USA TODAY NETWORK-Wisconsin / USA TODAY NETWORK