Saints starter makes another mistake that may cost him his job this week and open the door for younger player

The Saints need to look elsewhere for a new boot.

Adam Holt NFL News Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Nov 23, 2025; New Orleans, Louisiana, USA; New Orleans Saints head coach Kellen Moore on the field prior to a game against the Atlanta Falcons at Caesars Superdome. Mandatory Credit: Matthew Hinton-Imagn Images

The New Orleans Saints have plenty of roster concerns for their future. An issue that has plagued them this season and looms for years down the road is on special teams, though.

Kicker Blake Grupe showed improvement last season, but he has struggled massively this season. His inconsistency is glaring, and his latest mistake in Week 12 may push New Orleans to make a move.

Kicker Blake Grupe continues to struggle against Falcons

In the first quarter, following a huge return on a kickoff, Grupe missed a 38-yard field goal. That mistake heavily swung the momentum back in Atlanta’s favor. It seemed like New Orleans had a bit of a jump before the miss, but that quickly disappeared after another frustrating failure to convert for Grupe. After a solid drive just ahead of halftime, Grupe missed another attempt. In a game that should/could have been tied at 13, the Saints trailed 13-7.

Grupe is 17-of-25 on field goal attempts this year. That rate is among the worst in the NFL.

Charlie Smyth is on the Saints’ practice squad. He has a massive leg, but hasn’t gotten a true chance to kick in NFL games so far. New Orleans needs to look elsewhere because Grupe doesn’t seem like the long-term answer as the Saints’ kicker.

Even after the coaching staff recently showed some confidence in Grupe, you have to begin holding him accountable. He’s not getting the job done, so look elsewhere for your future kicker. He may even already be in the building.