Projected franchise tag values make it a near certainty that 49ers' former All-Pro will test the open market this offseason
The San Francisco 49ers' level of financial flexibility this offseason has been undersold. With over $48 million in projected cap space, they will still have plenty of room for maneuver even taking contract extensions for Brock Purdy and George Kittle into account, but the likelihood is they will still lose several players in free agency […]
The San Francisco 49ers' level of financial flexibility this offseason has been undersold. With over $48 million in projected cap space, they will still have plenty of room for maneuver even taking contract extensions for Brock Purdy and George Kittle into account, but the likelihood is they will still lose several players in free agency this year.
One of the headline names in that regard could be safety Talanoa Hufanga.
A first-team All-Pro in 2022, Hufanga has seen the last two seasons badly hindered by injury. A torn ACL suffered in Week 11 of the 2023 campaign prevented him from playing in Super Bowl LVIII, and he was limited to just seven games in 2024 owing to injuries.
The 49ers have spent picks on safeties in each of the last two drafts. San Francisco selected Ji'Ayir Brown in the third round in 2023 and then took Malik Mustapha in the fourth round last year.
Both enjoyed promising rookie seasons, with Mustapha seemingly penciling himself in as a long-term starter with his impressive versatility in coverage and his impact playing downhill against the run.
But a down year for Brown that saw him in and out of the lineup in 2024 could compel the Niners to make a more concerted attempt to keep a veteran with Hufanga's well-rounded playmaking skill set around.
San Francisco's options through which to do that are relatively limited, however.
Given the negotiations with Purdy and Kittle, the 49ers are likely to be reluctant to enter into discussions over a long-term deal with a player with a significantly checkered injury history. By the same token, Hufanga is unlikely to want to sign a prove-it deal without seeing what he can get on the open market.
The 49ers do have the franchise tag available to them, but, with the value of the tag for safeties set to be $19.6 million, according to Over The Cap, that does not appear to be a viable option considering the several other needs San Francisco has to address this offseason.
As such, if the 49ers do want Hufanga back, they will seemingly be forced to compete with rival teams for his services, with the odds of them coming to an agreement before the start of the legal tampering period looking slim.
It makes sense that San Francisco would ideally like to have a veteran presence on the safety depth chart on whom they can rely as an alternative to their recent draft picks.
Yet it seems unrealistic to expect the 49ers to get into any kind of bidding war for Hufanga if he has a robust market.
With veterans such as Jevon Holland and Justin Reid available in free agency and the 2025 draft featuring safety prospects whom the Niners could take early to shore up the position for the long term, the 49ers don't have a need to do anything drastic to keep Hufanga around, meaning the likelihood is he has played his last down for the team.
49ers are well placed to deliver on George Kittle’s warning to the rest of the league, if they make correct offseason decisions
They have the resources they need.