The question marks surrounding a couple of Tampa Bay franchise legends has some Bucs fans uneasy as the 2026 offseason gets into full swing. Mike Evans and Lavonte David — both locks to be in the franchise’s ring of honor and possessing Hall of Fame resumes — are free agents and their futures are unknown.

David has said recently that it’s returning to Tampa Bay or retirement for him, that he can’t see himself playing for another franchise.

Evans’ situation certainly isn’t the same and is a bit cloudier. He’s shown he’s still playing at a level that can help a number of teams, and he should have significant interest from plenty of suitors, which will include Tampa Bay, of course.

But where will he ultimately end up? ESPN’s Matt Bowen ranked the top 50 free agents of the 2026 NFL offseason and picked the best fit for each of them. Evans came in at No. 15, and Bowen thinks that Evans’ best landing spot would be catching passes from Josh Allen in Buffalo.

ESPN says Buffalo Bills are the best fit for Mike Evans in 2026

This is what Bowen had to say about Evans and landing in Buffalo:

“A return to Tampa Bay is clearly an option for Evans, but becoming the top receiver in Buffalo with quarterback Josh Allen makes a lot of sense, too. Under new coach Joe Brady, Evans could be that boundary X target for Allen and create matchups in the low red zone. I like the idea of Buffalo getting aggressive to add a proven and reliable target who had topped the 1,000-yard receiving mark in 11 straight seasons before injuries derailed his 2025 campaign.”

It’s hard to argue with the idea that Evans could help elevate Buffalo to that last step they need to get over the hump and reach the Super Bowl.

Well, at least theoretically. More to come on that in a bit.

Despite Allen putting up MVP numbers year in and year out, his targets, particularly at wideout, have been sorely underwhelming.

That shortcoming was evident for much of the season, as Allen, running back James Cook, and tight ends Dalton Kincaid and Dawson Knox contributed significantly in the passing game. Buffalo’s top wide receiver, Khalil Shakir, totaled 719 receiving yards during the regular season. The next highest total from a wide receiver was Keon Coleman with 404, which fell behind both Kincaid and Knox.

Simply put, Buffalo needs a difference maker, and Evans still has that potential even at age 32. If the Bills can fix some aspects of their defense, particularly up front against the run, they’re set to make a serious run at the Lombardi Trophy in 2026 with new head coach Joe Brady leading the way.

Whether Buffalo could make it happen with their salary cap constraints is another question

That all being said, while the fit would be awesome, the numbers till have to find a way to get worked out.

Buffalo is currently in salary cap jail for 2026. According to Over the Cap, the Bills rank as the fourth worst team in the NFL when it comes to effective salary cap space. They’re currently sitting around $16.45 million over the cap for effective cap space for 2026 at this point in time. They would have to get awfully creative with restructures and/or releases in order to make the necessary room for Evans.

---

Of course, the Bucs aren’t in the worst shape themselves for a 2026 run. They finished a tiebreaker away from returning to the playoffs, but their defense needs a significant overhaul itself, particularly at linebacker, both inside and outside.

If the Bucs can be competitive financially with Evans and can show how they play to address a sorely underperforming defense from 2025, then Bucs fans can be hopeful for another season of No. 13 in pewter and red.

But if Evans is indeed looking for a better opportunity and sees one elsewhere, then playing alongside Allen would be a very tempting option for the Bucs legend. If Buffalo can get themselves right financially, that is.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers News

Bucs 3-round 2026 NFL Mock Draft: Tampa Bay adds some defensive help, but passes on some potential difference makers

The Bucs have some crucial and obvious needs, but they didn’t get addressed in a recent mock draft.

Craig Smith