If you thought it was too early to start looking toward the 2026 NFL Draft, then you don't know how the A to Z Sports team works. Our expert evaluators had an eye on the 2026 class while studying for the 2025 draft, and Travis May has built out an insane three-round 2026 mock draft.

One class after the Ohio State Buckeyes produced 14 NFL draft picks, their total drops sharply in his latest mock. Only three Buckeyes made it. 

If the 2026 draft shakes out this way, there's a good chance Ohio State has not won the National Championship. Let's take a look at each of the three picks and give Travis' reasoning, plus other players to watch as risers.

Ohio State Buckeyes 2026 NFL Draft Prospects

7. Carolina Panthers: Caleb Downs, S Ohio State

If positional value didn't matter in the NFL Draft then Caleb Downs would be the first overall pick. He posted two near perfect seasons under his belt in coverage, added value in pass rush last fall, and will likely lock in top 10 draft capital this coming season. 

The Panthers already have one safety spot locked up with Trevon Moehrig, but Downs gives them one of the best secondaries in the league after this selection.

15. Arizona Cardinals: Carnell Tate, WR Ohio State

Carnell Tate flashed "next great Ohio State Buckeyes wide receiver" as soon as he stepped on campus, his very first spring. He would have been the WR1 for most every other team in the nation last year, but operated as the team's third target since he was sharing action with two other first-round picks in Emeka Egbuka (first round to the Buccaneers) and Jeremiah Smith (on a legitimate GOAT trajectory). 

If Tate can step up into Emeka Egbuka-level production this season there's no reason why he can't be a first round pick and the WR1 in a weaker 2026 class at the position.

41. Indianapolis Colts: Sonny Styles Jr., LB Ohio State

Other Buckeyes to Watch

• Ethan Onianwa, OT
• Brandon Inniss, WR
• Max Klare, TE
• CJ Donaldson, RB
• Caden Curry, EDGE
• Arvell Reese, LB
• Davison Igbinosun, CB