Michigan Wolverines and Sherrone Moore need to quit messing around and make the right choice at quarterback

It's the middle of October and Michigan Football is still messing around with making the right choice at quarterback. Throughout the spring and the entire offseason Sherrone Moore and his coaching staff refused to commit to a single quarterback. When they finally did, both failed rather spectacularly (Davis Warren and Alex Orji). Yes, Michigan is […]

Travis May College Football Managing Editor
Add as preferred source on Google
Oct 5, 2024; Seattle, Washington, USA; Michigan Wolverines quarterback Jack Tuttle (13) waits for a play to come in against the Washington Huskies during the third quarter at Alaska Airlines Field at Husky Stadium.
© Joe Nicholson-Imagn Images

It's the middle of October and Michigan Football is still messing around with making the right choice at quarterback. Throughout the spring and the entire offseason Sherrone Moore and his coaching staff refused to commit to a single quarterback. When they finally did, both failed rather spectacularly (Davis Warren and Alex Orji).

Yes, Michigan is still 4-2, but it's been with some of the most disgusting quarterback play in the history of the program. Michigan currently ranks 108th in yards per play, 117th in first down rate, and 126th in explosive play rate. That's just completely dysfunctional offense. If Michigan doesn't figure out their quarterback situation over the bye week this entire season is going to be a waste.

The team just needs to announce that Jack Tuttle is the starting quarterback moving forward and lean into what he does best. Or is it that simple?

After Sherrone Moore decided to put Jack Tuttle in the game against Washington it seemed that the offense saw their first spark of the season. The team scored on three straight drives and it looked like the Michigan offense was fixed. But of course things didn't end so smoothly after that, leaving key questions unanswered under center for the Wolverines.

However, despite the two turnovers late, Sherrone Moore's comments immediately following the game made it sound like Jack Tuttle was going to be the quarterback moving forward:

"I thought [Jack Tuttle] came out and gave us a spark early obviously. Three straight drives–you know–we had a touchdown, field goal, touchdown. So, I think the players fed off of that. He practiced well all week and got him back healthy which was great for us. You know, we'll see [about whether he'll be our starter moving forward]. But, it was positive. I think he gave us a spark so we'll see if he'll be the starter. Looks like he's given us the best chance. Obviously we've got to clean up the turnover at the end, but he definitely had an exciting start."

Head Coach Sherrone Moore didn't 100% declare that Jack Tuttle is "their guy" now, but it certainly sounds like he was excited to see the spark and early progress the offense made last week against Washington. If Moore commits to Tuttle for an entire week (or more) in practice there's a great chance that he shows he's the clear top option.

And based off of star running back Donovan Edwards' comments, it sounds like Tuttle wouldn't have any problem commanding the respect of the team if given a more extended opportunity:

"Yeah, I mean he just brought us a spark. Especially the play that he threw the touchdown to Colston [Loveland]. You know, it was just a big morale lift. I loved the way that before he went in the game he told everybody, 'Listen to me! Look at me!' Everybody just gave all their eyes to him. He has great leadership abilities and capabilities so I'm grateful that he got to go out there and was able to show what he can do."

It sounds like the team wants to give Jack Tuttle the job. Everything in pointing in that direction. It would just be nice for fans to have some clarity from the Michigan coaching staff on the most important position on the team. Hopefully Moore and his staff finally stop messing around soon and make the obviously correct decision in going with Jack Tuttle at quarterback.

Is there a ceiling to the style of play that Tuttle brings? Absolutely. He doesn't have a rocket arm or the tantalizing mobility of an Alex Orji. But what he does have is experience, and the ability to manage a game. Given the extreme bevy of talent Michigan has on the defensive side of the ball, all the Wolverines need is a game manager who can complete easy passes. That's what Jack Tuttle should bring.


Be looking for more Michigan Wolverines Football coverage here at A to Z Sports all year long! Follow me (@FF_TravisM) and A to Z Sports (@AtoZSportsNFL) on X for all the latest football news!