2025 five-star quarterback George MacIntyre, a Tennessee Vols commit since January, might not be referred to as a consensus five-star recruit for much longer. 

MacIntyre was poised to compete this week at the Elite 11 Finals in Los Angeles, but he had to pull out of the event due to an injury that hasn't completely healed yet. 

"Injury didn't heal in time and won't be able to make it," wrote MacIntyre in a post on his Instagram account. 

MacIntyre's withdrawal from the event was confirmed by Elite 11 on Monday night. 

Roster update:

Unfortunately, due to injury, George MacIntyre will not be able to participate in the 2024 Elite 11 Finals. We wish you a speedy & healthy recovery, @GeorgeMacIntyr6!

— Elite11 (@Elite11) June 18, 2024

Earlier this week, 247Sports' Grant Hughes pointed out that MacIntyre needs a good showing at the Elite 11 finals to keep from slipping in recruiting rankings. 

"Scouts have been underwhelmed with his camp performances this offseason, making a good showing at the Elite 11 Finals in June necessary if he wants to keep his arrow pointing up in the recruiting rankings," wrote Hughes. 

247Sports' Cooper Petagna echoed those sentiments recently. 

"This is a pivotal offseason for George MacIntyre," noted Petagna. "This is going to be a big week for him. You're going to see how he fits in with this group of elite arms. He's long, athletic and can get outside of the pocket. He does some good things. He's been underwhelming this offseason. Is he going to sink or swim when he gets out there with some of the best arms in the country? He's got a great opportunity in the next month to rebound and show what he is capable of."

On3's Charles Power is another recruiting analyst that pointed out this month that MacIntyre needs a strong showing at the Elite 11 Finals to avoid being jumped in recruiting rankings. 

From On3's Charles Power: MacIntyre is a tall passer with playmaking ability and solid athleticism. The Tennessee pledge had an up and down junior season while facing tough competition and did not look overly comfortable spinning the football in two separate camp outings this spring. In his defense, those were the his first two national level camps to our knowledge. Given the number of top talents currently behind him in the rankings, MacIntyre will need to show some improvement and stack up well within the group from an arm talent perspective to avoid being jumped.

MacIntyre doesn't need to prove anything. He's already locked in with Josh Heupel and the Vols so there's no need for him to push through an injury just to compete at a recruiting event so his ranking won't slip. 

The recruiting services do a tremendous job of evaluating talent. And they get more right than they get wrong. But their process isn't perfect. Players like MacIntyre often see their recruiting ranking slip because they commit to a program early during the recruiting cycle, reducing the need to perform at various recruiting camp stops. 

MacIntyre is currently rated as the No. 30 overall recruit in the 2025 recruiting class by 247Sports. He's rated as the No. 21 overall recruit in 247Sports' composite rankings. It's likely that MacIntyre slips just enough in the rankings (mostly because players who participate in camps will pass him) to lose his consensus five-star status. 

It's unfortunate for MacIntyre, who is likely to slip in the rankings simply because of the way the industry works. The Tennessee native has been a five-star recruit throughout the recruiting process, but it's very possible that he'll arrive in Knoxville later this winter as a recruit that's on the cusp of five-star status. It's an odd college football quirk that ultimately has no bearing on how a player will perform at the next level. 

Former Vols QB details wild season that includes Peyton Manning, Morgan Wallen, and running from autograph seekers with Hendon Hooker

2022 was an insane time at Tennessee