The Detroit Lions became contenders, and then being a fan got complicated

Detroit Lions fans waited a lifetime for meaningful football. Then it arrived. Somewhere between the NFC Championship Game and now, the feeling around this team changed in a way that’s hard to ignore.

Mike Payton Detroit Lions Beat Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Junfu Han / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

The Detroit Lions have built something special over the past four seasons, compiling four straight winning records for the first time since 1972. They remain one of the youngest teams in the NFL, loaded with All-Pro talent in its prime. The 2026 schedule projects as one of the easiest in the league. And yet the mood around this franchise feels different than it did two or three years ago. The excitement has shifted. The joy has curdled into something heavier. So here’s the question worth asking Lions fans right now: are you still having fun, or has this whole thing just become stressful?

I get it. I think when you hear that question, your first reaction might be defensive. The Lions are still going to be explosive. They’re still going to run trick plays. You’re still going to want their guys on your fantasy team. That’s not what I’m talking about. What I’m asking is whether the emotional experience of being a Lions fan has changed from pure thrill to something closer to dread.

The rise was the best part

Think about where this started. In 2021, we all expected that team to be bad. Then they beat Minnesota, and something clicked. You could see the vision. A few weeks later, they knocked off the Arizona Cardinals, who were one of the best teams in the league at the time, and the whole fanbase collectively said, “All right, the Lions are coming.”

Then 2022 happened. A brutal 1-7 start gave way to an unbelievable finish. I remember getting done covering a game that year and telling my wife I couldn’t believe what I was watching. They just kept rattling off wins and finding ways to close out games. It felt like a movement. It was a moment in time that Detroit had never experienced.

And 2023 was the peak of emotions most Lions fans didn’t even know they could feel. The first NFC North championship since 1991. A lot of fans hadn’t been alive for that. A lot of people forget the Lions had never actually won the NFC North. They won the old NFC Central. So this was history. Then they reached the NFC Championship Game, and at halftime, you felt something you had probably never felt in your entire life. The Lions were a half away from the Super Bowl. Everything you had ever dreamed of was right there.

They fell short. That was painful. But you came out of that game knowing 2024 was going to be the year. The hype that summer was unlike anything this city had ever produced. The NFL Draft came to Detroit. Fans were chanting Jared Goff’s name at stadiums across the city. Then the Lions went 15-2, and even with injuries piling up, you still believed it was possible.

Where the fun went

The loss to Washington in the playoffs was supposed to be the price of doing business. You told yourself that’s just what happens when you’re good. You can’t be happy all the time. But then 2025 came, and the feeling changed. It went from “I can’t believe this is happening” to “just do it already.” The Lions missed the playoffs, and suddenly the whole thing started feeling less like a ride and more like a burden.

That’s the shift. The fun has gone from “Can they do this?” and “Oh my God, is it going to happen?” to “Why won’t it just happen already?” Why does this team keep coming up short? Why do I as a fan have to keep going through this? Those are different emotions. They’re heavier. They’re not as enjoyable.

The window is not closed

Now, I want to be clear about something. I am the last person on planet Earth who is going to push the “Lions window is closing” narrative when they’re the sixth-youngest team in the league and still have a bunch of All-Pro players in their prime. If we’re going to play the injury game, Kerby Joseph is maybe the only guy they’re probably not going to get back, and even that is a huge maybe at this point. Brian Branch, Sam LaPorta, and the rest of this core are still here.

This is still a good football team. Four straight winning seasons for the first time in over 50 years. That matters. But the emotional reality for fans has changed, and I think that’s worth acknowledging. Being a contender year after year is something most Lions fans have never dealt with. The expectations that come with it are brand new.

So I want to know what you’re feeling. Are you still having a good time? Or are you just ready for it to happen, and anything less than a Super Bowl feels like a total disappointment? There’s no wrong answer. But it’s a question worth sitting with, because this version of the Lions isn’t going anywhere.