The NFL used to pride itself on being the league of parity, but now finds itself in the least diverse period of the Super Bowl Era

If it feels like the same teams always play for the Super Bowl these days, it’s because they do

Easton Freeze Tennessee Titans Beat Writer
Add as preferred source on Google

My favorite thing about the National Football league is the parity. But lately, that's been missing in the biggest game of the year.

The NFL has long prided itself on being the greatest reality TV show in the world. The drama is constant, and you never quite know what's going to happen next. It's the "any given Sunday' league. It's the league where you can fall from first to last just as quickly as you can rise from last to first. It's the league where one star can change everything for a franchise. Where once you get into the playoffs, most every team has a chance to win.

That's the elevator pitch for the NFL. But for nearly the past decade, that reputation falls flat when we reach the Super Bowl. The Chiefs and the Eagles just played in Super Bowl LIX, a rematch of their 2023 Super Bowl matchup. It's the first SB rematch since… last season, when the Chiefs faced the 49ers in a rematch of the 2020 SB.

When it feels like the same teams have been playing for the SB lately, it's because they have. In the last 8 years, there have been 8 Super Bowls. That means an opportunity for 16 different teams to play in the game, or half the league. But from 2018-2025, only 7 teams have made it to the final game of the season.

2018-2025

TEAMYEARS

Eagles

2018, 2023, 2025

Patriots

2018, 2019

Rams

2019, 2022

Chiefs

2020, 2023, 2024, 2025

49ers

2020, 2024

Buccaneers

2021

Bengals

2022

7 different teams, 5 with multiple trips (breaks up Patriots going in 4 of 5 years)

Two of these 8 games have been rematches of 2 of the others. 5 of the 7 teams have been multiple times in this period, with the Eagles going three times and the Chiefs four. For the length of two full presidential terms, the AFC has been represented by just the Chiefs and Patriots with a brief Bengals cameo, and the NFC represented by the Eagles, Rams and 49ers, with a brief Buccaneers cameo. It's been painfully repetitive.

When you split the entire Super Bowl era up into these 8 year chunks going all the way back through the 70's, you realize just how unusual it's been. In fact the past 8 years (7 different teams, 5 making multiple trips) have been the least diverse run of Super Bowls ever, with the only era coming close being 1970-1977. During those eight years, 8 different teams went with 4 making multiple trips.

On average, every 8 years we've seen around 11 different teams play in the Super Bowl. Here's who we saw every 8 years dating back to 1970 for reference.

2010-2017

TEAMYEAR

Saints

2010

Colts

2010

Packers

2011

Steelers

2011

Giants

2012

Patriots

2012, 2015, 2017

Ravens

2013

49ers

2013

Seahawks

2014, 2015

Broncos

2014, 2016

Panthers

2016

Falcons

2017

12 different teams, 3 with multiple trips

2002-2009

TEAMYEAR

Patriots

2002, 2004, 2005, 2008

Rams

2002

Buccaneers

2003

Raiders

2003

Panthers

2004

Eagles

2005

Steelers

2006, 2009

Seahawks

2006

Colts

2007

Bears

2007

Giants

2008

Cardinals

2009

12 different teams, 2 with multiple trips

1994-2001

TEAMYEAR

Cowboys

1994, 1996

Bills

1994

49ers

1995

Chargers

1995

Steelers

1996

Packers

1997, 1998

Patriots

1997

Broncos

1998, 1999

Falcons

1999

Rams

2000

Titans

2000

Ravens

2001

Giants

2001

13 different teams, 3 with multiple trips (splits up the Cowboys going in 3 of 4 years)

1986-1993

TEAMYEAR

Bears

1986

Patriots

1986

Giants

1987, 1991

Broncos

1987, 1988, 1990

Redskins

1988, 1990

49ers

1989, 1990

Bengals

1989

Bills

1991, 1992, 1993

Cowboys

1993

9 different teams, 5 with multiple trips (splits up the Bills going in 4 of 4 years)

1978-1985

TEAMYEAR

Cowboys

1978, 1979

Broncos

1978

Steelers

1979, 1980

Rams

1980

Raiders

1981, 1984

Eagles

1981

49ers

1982, 1985

Bengals

1982

Redskins

1983, 1984

Dolphins

1983, 1985

10 different teams, 6 with multiple trips

1970-1977

TEAMYEAR

Chiefs

1970

Vikings

1970, 1974, 1975, 1977

Baltimore Colts

1971

Cowboys

1971, 1972, 1976

Dolphins

1972, 1973, 1974

Redskins

1973

Steelers

1975, 1976

Raiders

1977

8 different teams, 4 with multiple trips (splits up Steelers going in 4 of 6 years, and Cowboys going in 3 of 4 years)

The real pinnacle of NFL Super Bowl parity came between the Bills four consecutive losses from 1991-1994, and when the Tom Brady Patriots began their reign of terror going in 3 of 4 years beginning in 2002. In the 7 Super Bowls between those runs, 12 different teams played in the big game with only the Packers and Broncos going twice. Now that's parity!

But every era in the history of the Super Bowl has experienced more parity than the one we currently find ourselves in. I suppose that's the good news and the bad news of it all: it's never been worse than it is right now, but history tells us that parity is likely to reign supreme again soon. Let's hope that it does.