San Francisco 49ers' ability to excel at potential problem area will hinge on starters’ subtle quality

The holes in the San Francisco 49ers' defense are tough to find. San Francisco revamped an extremely talented defensive line this offseason and, while the seemingly likely absence of linebacker Dre Greenlaw for at least some of the 2024 season will hurt, having the best player in the game at that position in Fred Warner […]

Add as preferred source on Google
Nov 12, 2023; Jacksonville, Florida, USA; San Francisco 49ers safety Talanoa Hufanga (29) and teammates celebrate a fumble recovery during the third quarter at EverBank Stadium.
Morgan Tencza-USA TODAY Sports

The holes in the San Francisco 49ers' defense are tough to find.

San Francisco revamped an extremely talented defensive line this offseason and, while the seemingly likely absence of linebacker Dre Greenlaw for at least some of the 2024 season will hurt, having the best player in the game at that position in Fred Warner should ensure the drop-off without his running mate is not too steep.

Having added a lot of depth to the cornerback position behind starters Charvarius Ward and Deommodore Lenoir, San Francisco's secondary was recently ranked as the second best in the NFL by Pro Football Focus. 

But within that secondary there is a potential weakness, even though the 49ers are likely to be very confident in their options. 

The 49ers are set to start Ji'Ayir Brown and Talanoa Hufanga at safety in 2024, the latter coming off a torn ACL in November that thrust Brown into the starting lineup late in his rookie season.

Brown impressed over the course of five regular-season starts and a postseason campaign in which he had an interception of Patrick Mahomes in the 49ers' Super Bowl 58 defeat to the Kansas City Chiefs. Hufanga, of course, has significant pedigree as a playmaker from the safety position, having been named a first-team All-Pro in his first season as a starter in 2022.

Yet the 49ers don't have much depth to protect against Hufanga suffering any setbacks in his recovery from injury, with competition for Brown in case he struggles to take a second-year leap consisting of rookie fourth-round pick Malik Mustapha.

Beyond the depth issue, though, there is no guarantee that Brown and Hufanga will coalesce working together. 

Brown and Hufanga have never started together on the 49er defense, but one of the latter's more subtle traits will be key to ensuring their partnership is a success.

Speaking about Hufanga back in May, new defensive coordinator Nick Sorensen said:"[The] main thing with him is he’s got experience and he is a heck of a player. 

"I mean, he’s really, really good at communicating, he’s smart, he sees things, has a full understanding of our system, and when he gets back we’re going to be excited."

It is that communication with Brown that will be critical to the 49ers' safeties being a strength of the team in 2024. The 49ers have typically rotated their safeties' responsibilities regularly, with Hufanga playing a varied role because of his ability to make plays at all three levels.

The onus on strong communication will only increase if assistant head coach Brandon Staley, who will have a big influence on the defense, and Sorensen agree on tweaks that see a greater use of disguise and more creatively designed blitzes.

Brown, though, displayed excellent awareness during his time on the field, with his instincts key to his success in making plays on the ball as a rookie after being catapulted into the starting line up.

Both Brown and Hufanga are aggressive and versatile playmakers with a knack for being in the right place at the right time. Their communication and ability to make sure they are on the same page will go a long way in determining whether a safety duo with the potential to be one of the most exciting in the NFL can realize that upside.