The Indianapolis Colts were all-in on Anthony Richardson going into the 2023 NFL Draft. When he was on the board at No. 4 overall, the Colts did not flinch at adding the most athletic quarterback in NFL Draft history to the roster.

Richardson seems to be the ideal fit for first-year head coach Shane Steichen and his run-heavy offense. Steichen loves to use his quarterback's arm and legs to burn defenses, which matches up with Richardson's strengths well.

Indianapolis made the decision to restart their quarterback position with a rookie rather than going after MVP Lamar Jackson in free agency. There was some early smoke that Indy would make a run for Jackson, but that turned out to not be the case.

"Anytime a special player is available, which he is, you've got to do the work," Colts general manager Chris Ballard said of Jackson in March. "I think anytime at that position we have a chance to acquire a guy, you've got do your work on it to see if it's doable."

Going after Jackson would have cost the Colts multiple first-round draft picks and a hefty, record-setting deal. In the end, Indianapolis opted to go for the exciting rookie in Richardson who will be playing on a rookie contract.

That strategy will be put the test – rightfully or wrongfully – early in the 2023 NFL season. Because Indianapolis will take on the Baltimore Ravens in week three of the schedule on the road. 

Jackson ended up agreeing to a lofty contract with the Ravens and will be on the other side of the matchup when the Colts take the field. He is one of the most dynamic players in the league and will put stress on Indy's defense.

Regardless of the result, Indianapolis will still be happy with their decision about going with Richardson. Nevertheless, the strategy to go with the rookie over a proven player will be under the microscope.