Giants’ Abdul Carter questions validity of major issue highlighted in a concerning recent report

New York Giants rookie Abdul Carter responded to a recent report that questioned his work ethic

Joe DeLeone NFL News Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Oct 19, 2025; Denver, Colorado, USA; New York Giants linebacker Abdul Carter (51) reacts after a play against the Denver Broncos during the second half at Empower Field at Mile High.
Ron Chenoy-Imagn Images

New York Giants fans were confused as to why rookie pass rusher Abdul Carter was not in the game for the opening series against the Green Bay Packers yesterday.

Without Kayvon Thibodeaux, it was perplexing as to why the former first-round pick wasn’t seeing an increased role. Eventually, Carter stepped in and played the remaining defensive snaps, registering two pressures and one tackle.

This morning, it was reported by Dan Duggan of The Athletic that there was a reason for Carter’s absence. According to Duggan, Carter was asleep in the facility during a team walkthrough and was being held accountable by interim head coach Mike Kafka.

Carter went public with the matter, replying to Duggan’s tweet and clarifying that he was actually doing recovery work. He took accountability for his mistake, but has now created a he-said, he-said situation.

Abdul Carter responds to rumors

Immediately following yesterday’s 27-20 loss to the Packers, Kafka was asked about the situation with Carter. He said it was a decision he made, but wouldn’t clarify what went down.

“It was my decision, we’ll keep the rest of that in house,” Kafka told reporters after the game.

Today, Carter fired off another post, essentially accusing Duggan of lying because efforts to drag him down weren’t working.

According to Duggan’s report, this wasn’t a one-off instance with Carter. He reportedly showed up late to meetings under Brian Daboll’s watch.

While Carter has shown promise this season by generating 37 pressures, his 0.5 sacks through 11 games are underwhelming. His lack of sack production may have been the context we’ve been missing if he hasn’t been taking preparation seriously. Additionally, it further supports my point that Daboll should have been fired because he wasn’t focusing enough on the small details to help the team progress and win.

A layer to this that should be recognized is Kafka’s handling of the situation. Stepping in as the interim coach, he had no reason to hold a player accountable for something the past coach had ignored. It’s also a significant risk to make a statement like that at the risk of immediately losing the locker room. Instead, Kafka deserves respect for recognizing that if he wants to take advantage of his seven-game audition, he needs to start addressing the little issues.

Yesterday, Kafka also took time to praise Carter as a player and emphasize the respect he has for him.

“I’m really happy about Abdul. Excited to watch him continue to grow and continue to play a lot more as a pro,” Kafka stated, “I love Abdul and what he brings to this team. The skillset he has. This guy loves ball. And I’m excited to watch him attack this week of practice and continue to work and grow to be the great player I think he is.”

This saga is either another blemish during a disappointing season or a turning point for a team needing to lock back in.