6 winners and 4 losers from the Lions’ 35-10 demolition of the Patriots, including one potentially devastating loss
The Lions dominated the Patriots in Germany behind huge performances from Jahmyr Gibbs and Amon-Ra St. Brown, but Aidan Hutchinson’s injury and a few concerning performances put a damper on the victory. Here are six winners and four losers.
The Detroit Lions went to Munich, Germany, and stomped the reigning AFC champions. Detroit beat the New England Patriots 35-10, and it was never really in doubt.
Look, I know what you’re going to say. Drake Maye went down early, and New England was out there with Tommy DeVito, an injured A.J. Brown, and no TreVeyon Henderson. It doesn’t matter. You play who’s in front of you. We’ve seen plenty of Lions teams lose to backups. This one didn’t. Sure, New England scoring its only touchdown when it was 28-3 had people breathing heavily for a second. There was some sloppiness on offense, too. Other than that, the Lions handled their business.
The first thing everyone wants to know about is Aidan Hutchinson. I know as much as you do. Lions coach Dan Campbell said at the podium that the team had no updates on Hutchinson and wouldn’t know anything until it got back to the States. We usually hear from Campbell the day after games. Nothing is scheduled yet, but something will probably come up. We’ll likely know more by Tuesday.
One more thing. The German outlet RAN took a picture of Hutchinson leaving the stadium on crutches. People are asking if it’s fake. It’s not. RAN is a real outlet, and that really happened. That’s not great solace, but at least you know what you’re looking at.
Now let’s get to the winners and losers.
The winners
Amon-Ra St. Brown
You have to understand what this game meant to him. His mother is German, he spent time living in Germany, and he speaks the language fluently. On Detroit’s first drive, he decided he was getting into the end zone, and nobody was stopping him. That 56-yard touchdown had him making everyone miss. He finished with four catches for 98 yards and two touchdowns, and the second one was a full-team push into the end zone. Watching him run out with the German flag and get treated like a hometown hero was just cool.
Jahmyr Gibbs
He had 252 yards from scrimmage and two touchdowns. The strange part is it feels normal, and it shouldn’t. A running back going for 252 yards is not just a Sunday in Germany. When you get him in space, he’s unbelievable.
Roger McCreary
Per Pro Football Focus’ instant grades, which can shift a bit after review, McCreary was Detroit’s highest-graded defender. He played 59 snaps with a 90 defensive grade and a 91 coverage grade. He was targeted four times, allowed two catches for 10 yards, grabbed an interception, and allowed a passer rating of 16.7. The Lions didn’t trade for a cornerback at the deadline, and I know that upset people. A game like this, with D.J. Reed likely coming back next week, should calm some nerves. Teams keep picking on McCreary like he’s the liability. Let them keep thinking that.
Rock Ya-Sin
It wasn’t a good start to the season for him, but he’s played better since getting benched for a minute. He was targeted five times and allowed one catch for five yards. He did miss a tackle, which is probably why PFF graded him lower than I would have.
Derrick Barnes
He was flying all over the place early, with a couple of tackles for loss and a pass breakup. Everyone was worried about the middle linebacker spot without Jack Campbell. Barnes has played it well. Malcolm Rodriguez and Trevor Nowaske had solid games, too, and Devin White should be back sooner rather than later.
Derrick Moore
He played a career-high 40 snaps and put up four pressures and two sacks. That’s back-to-back two-sack games. He’s not a finished project. There’s work to do in the run game and some in the pass rush. But he’s making things happen, and whatever happens with Hutchinson, you want Moore to keep growing like this. The defensive line as a whole had 16 pressures and five sacks. Hutchinson had two of those pressures and one of those sacks before he went out, and Alim McNeill looked good, too.
The losers
I’m not calling anyone a bad person here. These guys just had a bad day.
Aidan Hutchinson:
I’m not a doctor, and I don’t know what this is. What I do know is he got hurt celebrating. There’s nothing wrong with celebrating, but jumping celebrations don’t always end well. Lions fans remember Stephen Tulloch. I’m not saying that’s what happened here.
To the fans calling Hutchinson selfish or dumb, relax. That’s childish, and it helps nobody. This was a guy who was happy he made a play and did what every other player does.
If he’s out for the season, the Lions are going to have to find a way, and they can’t absorb many more injuries after that. He missed most of 2024, and that team still went 15-2. With this offense and a defense that has turned around this much, Detroit can still do a lot.
Update: We now know that it is a serious knee injury for Hutchinson.
Jared Goff:
I could almost put him with the winners. He went 20-of-31 for 303 yards and three touchdown passes. But he also threw two ugly interceptions, and the one in the end zone before halftime was on him. He had St. Brown open right in front of him and went for Jameson Williams in the back of the end zone. This should have been 42-10. He came out of the bye without an interception and now has four in three games. That’s not a reason to panic, but it’s worth keeping in mind.
Nick Whiteside
After a great start to training camp, he played seven snaps, and none of them went well. His defensive pass interference led to the Patriots’ touchdown. He’s on the 53-man roster and will get more chances, but he has to be better.
Ennis Rakestraw:
He also had a DPI in just five snaps. There were only 59 defensive snaps to go around, with Ya-Sin playing 55 and Khalil Dorsey playing 21 before getting hurt. I just don’t know where I’m at with Rakestraw. Christian Mahogany has stepped forward from that 2024 class. You’re hoping for more from Rakestraw, and we haven’t seen it yet.
We’ll see what the next few days bring on Hutchinson.

Detroit Lions News
