9 winners and 3 losers from San Francisco 49ers’ wild win over Cowboys as Christian McCaffrey delivers historic performance
San Francisco’s offense erupted for 584 yards in a thrilling victory over Dallas, but several defensive struggles nearly overshadowed extraordinary performances from its biggest stars.
The San Francisco 49ers got the job done in Dallas, and it doesn’t matter how it looked at the finish. A 46-40 road win over the Dallas Cowboys had plenty of 49ers fans’ hearts racing. A win is a win, and San Francisco now turns its attention to a big matchup with Seattle next week.
The winners list from this one is a long one, especially on the offensive side of the football. Let’s start there.
Winners
QB Brock Purdy
Brock Purdy was phenomenal. He threw for 389 yards and three touchdown passes, and he finished with only six incompletions. Purdy extended plays and made things happen on the move all day long. If he wants to climb back to the top of the MVP race, this is how he does it.
What a phenomenal day from No. 13.
RB Christian McCaffrey
This was an all-time performance from Christian McCaffrey. He ran for over 60 yards and a touchdown, then added 161 receiving yards and two more scores through the air. One of those was the game-clinching touchdown in the fourth quarter, and he followed it up with the two-point conversion.
Simply put, it was an astonishing day from CMC.
WR Keenan Allen
Allen posted a solid stat line with five catches for 61 yards, and he got going early. Now, consider the context. Allen was just traded to San Francisco.
He has had limited reps with Purdy in Shanahan’s system, which is a tough offense to learn. He still made it happen and gave the pass-catching group a great veteran presence.
WR Deebo Samuel
Deebo Samuel caught a touchdown pass early, then ripped off the longest rushing touchdown of his career on a beautiful 70-yard reverse. I don’t think anybody on the Dallas defense knew that play was coming. They were completely fooled. It was a great day from Samuel in his gadget role.
HC Kyle Shanahan
The 49ers piled up 584 yards of total offense, the most the Cowboys have ever allowed in a home game. Kyle Shanahan deserves a ton of credit for that, like he does every week. San Francisco has dealt with injuries and plenty of roster turnover, and Shanahan has still had this offense ready to play every single week.
RB Kaelon Black
The rookie had a beautiful touchdown run, breaking through two tacklers on his way to the end zone. The late fumble scare nearly handed Dallas an extra shot, and he has to clean up his ball security. He’s really getting going, though, and that’s encouraging.
CB Renardo Green
Renardo Green battled all day. He did give up some plays, but he had good coverage on a couple of deep shots from the Cowboys. Overall, he competed and played a solid game for San Francisco.
There is a lot of promise for his future, I truly believe.
DT Osa Odighizuwa
Osa Odighizuwa was a problem up front. He finished with two quarterback hits and a tackle for loss, and he clogged up running lanes from start to finish. The presence of DeForest Buckner is opening up some opportunities for Odighizuwa and he seems to be taking advantage.
S Malik Mustapha
Malik Mustapha was flying around and laying the wood in the secondary. He now has an interception in back-to-back games, and he turned in another strong performance.
Losers
CB Deommodore Lenoir
Deommodore Lenoir struggled in coverage all day. He made a couple of nice plays, but Cowboys WR George Pickens had his way with him and most of the 49ers secondary. Lenoir is scrappy and I expect him to play better going forward, but man today was bad.
OL Connor Colby
Connor Colby had a rough day up front. Cowboys DT Quinnen Williams gave him trouble all game long. Colby gave up an early sack to Williams and looked to be a little uncomfortable at times.
LB Garret Wallow
Garret Wallow committed a costly special teams penalty on a long kick return from 49ers RB Jordan James to begin the second half. In a game this close, those mistakes can sometimes add up. Field position is crucial and dumb penalties like that have the ability to wipe it all away.
Seattle is up next
This wasn’t a clean win, and the defense has work to do. Still, an offense that hangs 584 yards on the road is a scary group to line up against. With Purdy playing at an MVP level and McCaffrey doing everything, I think San Francisco carries this momentum right into the Minnesota game and keeps rolling.

