‘You really watched him just piss a game away’ – The Tennessee Vols may have avoided one of the biggest mistakes of the Josh Heupel era

A move that Tennessee didn’t make this past offseason may be the best thing that could’ve happened for the Vols in 2026.

Zach Ragan — Tennessee Volunteers News Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Tennessee Vols football
Brianna Paciorka/USA TODAY Network

A move that didn’t work out the way some Vols fans were hoping it would may be the best thing that could’ve happened to Tennessee in 2026.

Back in January, a significant portion of the Vols fan base was hoping Tennessee would close the deal with Arizona State transfer quarterback Sam Leavitt.

Leavitt, though, ended up transferring to LSU after Tigers head coach Lane Kiffin flew to the Knoxville airport (as Leavitt’s visit to Tennessee concluded) to convince the coveted transfer to play in Baton Rouge.

Kiffin’s decision to stalk Leavitt in Knoxville worked and the Arizona State transfer chose LSU over Tennessee and Miami.

“I don’t know. I just know how I do things,” said Kiffin in February when asked about following Leavitt to Knoxville. “There’s a good and bad to it. I’m extremely competitive, and I don’t really do well with no — that just makes me more competitive when someone says no.”

After Tennessee missed on Leavitt, they also learned that Joey Aguilar, the Vols’ starter in 2025, wasn’t granted another season of eligibility. That left Tennessee with sophomore George MacIntyre (nine career pass attempts entering the season) and true freshman Faizon Brandon as its top two options at quarterback.

Having two inexperienced quarterbacks has led to some uneven moments on offense for the Vols this season — they’re just a couple of plays away from being 10-0 right now — but it’s probably a better situation than Tennessee would be in had Leavitt landed on Rocky Top.

Sam Leavitt wasn’t a good fit for Tennessee’s biggest strength this season

Leavitt is a talented athlete with experience, but he doesn’t play the style of football that is best suited for the 2026 Volunteers.

The 2026 Vols are a team that controls the clock, takes care of the football, and closes games in the fourth quarter (Tennessee has outscored its last two opponents, Kentucky and Texas A&M, 34-0 in the fourth quarter).

“You play three quarters to get to the fourth quarter — that’s what you do in this league,” said former Vols assistant coach Doug Matthews on Big Orange Sunday this week. “You play 45 minutes to get to the final 15 minutes. … That’s where you win in this league.”

College football host Josh Pate pointed out on Sunday, after LSU’s loss to Texas, that Leavitt is a player who doesn’t value taking care of the football, and he hasn’t been good at closing games in the fourth quarter.

“Sam Leavitt now is tied for most interceptions in FBS,” said Pate. “I don’t think he values possessing the football enough. The way he operates and the throws he makes, I really don’t think he values the most precious commodity — which is the football. It’s like you throw it up, and whatever happens, happens. In the red zone and it’s a 50-50 shot [and he will just] throw it up. That’s not what 50-50 throws are supposed to be. A 50/50 throw is supposed to either be your guy or nobody. It’s not your guy or their guy, and that’s kind of what I think Sam Leavitt thinks a 50/50 ball is.

“You’ve watched him do it all year. You’ve specifically watched him the last couple of weeks [do that], and you really watched him [against Texas] just piss a game away to the point where you look at it in the fourth quarter — Steve Sarkisian had watched Arch Manning make some mistakes, but he still had faith in him — and Lane Kiffin had no faith in Sam Leavitt, and he shouldn’t have any faith in Sam Leavitt.”

“They (LSU) are mentally weak at quarterback, and just culturally, it’s not strong enough,” added Pate. “… LSU has mastered finding every which way to lose, and now they’ve done it four times. There is no signature win here. It’s just such an unclutch group.”

Leavitt wasn’t the right fit for Tennessee. I think the Vols were smart to pursue Leavitt — leave no stone unturned — but they made the right decision to not keep pushing once the bidding got out of hand for the former four-star recruit.

The word culture gets overused in sports, but it’s still incredibly important. It’s nearly impossible to win a championship in college football without being a connected team who plays for each other and isn’t out there trying to make hero plays on every drive.

If the Vols had landed Leavitt, they very well may be in the same position as LSU right now — out of the playoff picture before Thanksgiving.

Play A to Z Daily Games