Titans defense sinks to new low against Jaguars, and Robert Saleh’s effort argument only goes so far

The Jaguars marched up and down the field in Nashville, and the problems with this Tennessee defense run deeper than the two stars who were traded away. Robert Saleh is running out of answers.

Buck Reising — Tennessee Titans Beat Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Robert Saleh is being let down by the group he coaches.
Nov 1, 2026; Cincinnati, Ohio, USA; Tennessee Titans head coach Robert Saleh looks on during overtime against the Cincinnati Bengals at Paycor Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Katie Stratman-Imagn Images

NASHVILLE — The Tennessee Titans (1-8) fell 40-23 to the Jacksonville Jaguars on Sunday. The offense did enough to keep pace for most of the afternoon, but a defensive trend over the last three games is now the biggest cause for concern in Tennessee.

This may be the worst stretch of Titans defensive football I’ve seen.

Cam Ward and the offense are doing enough to win

Quarterback Cam Ward was far from perfect. His interception came shortly after the Titans picked off Trevor Lawrence, and it handed Jacksonville good field position. From the press box, the throw looked a bit behind receiver Elic Ayomanor. It wasn’t an egregious miss, though, and Jaguars’ Travis Hunter made a great snag on it. Ward said he would throw that ball again, just with a little more on it to give Ayomanor a better chance.

This was not a losing performance by the quarterback. It wasn’t a great performance by the offense either, but it was good enough.

Tennessee opened this season with an offense scoring fewer than 12 points per game. Since the Houston game, the Titans have scored 26 in their win over Indianapolis, 24 against Cleveland, 36 against Cincinnati, and 23 against Jacksonville. You should be able to win games when the offense plays like that.

Ward was asked about the defensive letdowns and if they’re a reflection of the offense’s mindset when it wasn’t holding up its end of the bargain.

“We all have to do more,” said Ward. “What I preach to them is we’re not playing complementary football. We’re doing it at key times, but we’re not doing the whole game. If you don’t do it the whole game, you know, you’re gonna constantly find yourself losing 3-, 7-point games. So, uh, we [have to] start to play, you know, together on every play, (in) every aspect of the game, whether [the] defense gives up a touchdown, we gotta respond. We scored, [the] defense needs to get a stop. So, you know, it’s both sides, not just one, but (we’ll) continue to try to build together.”

The Titans defense cannot get off the field

The Jaguars piled up 459 total yards and converted 7 of 14 third downs. Tennessee went 2 of 11 on third down. Box score scouting isn’t everything, but that split tells the story.

The trend is not new. The Browns, hardly an offensive juggernaut, racked up 491 yards. The Bengals put up 440 yards and 43 points. Even the Colts compiled 399 yards despite Tennessee turning quarterback Daniel Jones over repeatedly.

Jacksonville is rolling, of course. Per ESPN Insights, the 8-2 Jaguars have a +125 point differential, the best by any team through its first nine games since the 2021 Bills (+145). It is also the second-best mark through nine games in franchise history, trailing only the 1999 Jaguars (+137) who reached the AFC Championship Game.

Receiver Parker Washington looked like a true No. 1. Per Pro Football Focus numbers shared by John Glennon on X, cornerback Alontae Taylor allowed seven catches on seven targets for 143 yards. Joshua Williams, the new outside corner, allowed six catches on seven targets for 86 yards and two touchdowns. Cor’Dale Flott, the best of the bunch, allowed four catches on six targets for 55 yards and a touchdown.

There’s no juice up front, either. Edge rusher Jacob Martin, who has a career-high 7.5 sacks, is the only consistent pass rush presence. He should be part of the plan going forward. Jermaine Johnson should not be retained, not because he’s a problem, but because he isn’t an impactful player. Rookie Keldrick Faulk still hasn’t shown anything of consequence on Sundays, and neither Femi Oladejo nor Solomon Thomas is moving the needle.

Losing Jeffery Simmons and Amani Hooker created a drop-off. However, the yardage totals were similar when both were playing. That’s an easy excuse, and it doesn’t hold up.

Robert Saleh is getting effort, not results

Head coach Robert Saleh doesn’t have the players to compete at the level he needs to. He can’t say that publicly, especially at 1-8, a worse start than both Brian Callahan and Ken Whisenhunt had in Tennessee.

Saleh was asked if there’s a world where he can get more out of the current group of players on the roster.

“I thought we played our asses off today,” said Saleh. “Like, I know the scoreboard is what it is, but our guys played their asses off. And, you know, it’s 40-20. I know it says 40-23, but that is not indicative of what I felt this game was. I felt like it was a heck of a lot closer there, especially in the fourth quarter. We’re sitting there 30-23 with a chance to get the ball back, and credit to those guys that made a play to extend the drive and get points on. Regardless it was a little bit of a back and forth.

“[We] felt like we had our opportunities to kind of tie the game. Even coming out of the locker room, had a chance to go take a lead having the ball, but we got points on. So again, I thought our guys gave us everything they had. Unfortunately they made more plays than we did.”

I believe him on the effort. Unlike last year, nobody is questioning whether these Titans are trying. They’re just worse, which is crazy to say.

Robert Saleh said at 1-7 that this isn’t a 1-7 football team, and general manager Mike Borgonzi said the same. Parts of this roster are better. Still, this is a 1-8 football team in every sense of the word.

Robert Saleh is an excellent defensive play caller, and he’s allowed time to figure this out. His first season will be judged by whether that defense shows growth, even with lacking personnel. Right now, the miscommunications are killing Tennessee, and the cycle keeps repeating itself.

Play A to Z Daily Games