ESPN’s Greg McElroy has a very bold take on CFP rankings shakeup that could be coming for the Tennessee Vols
The former Alabama QB sees a ranking that some have considered a wrong being righted on Tuesday night.
It was an overall successful weekend for the Tennessee Vols on Saturday in College Station, Texas. The Vols started off slow against the Texas A&M Aggies, but they got going in the second half and turned a 7-6 deficit into a 22-7 win over the final 17 minutes of the game.
It’s a win that should impress the committee t0 some degree regardless of A&M’s record of 4-6. Going on the road is never easy, and doing it in front of 100,000+ screaming fans is even tougher.
But who didn’t face 100,000+ screaming fans was Alabama, who also ground their way to an SEC road win, prevailing at Vanderbilt 21-6. Beyond the result, it was not a great weekend for the Crimson Tide’s resume. Kentucky lost to Florida. South Carolina got blown out by Arkansas 34-6. LSU picked up loss number four against Texas. Mississippi State got dog walked by Auburn 41-9.
As such, could this be a weekend where the Crimson Tide drop significantly in the rankings like Indiana did last week after a bye? Former Tide QB and current ESPN college football commentator and analyst Greg McElroy thinks so.
McElroy discussed the upcoming rankings on Sunday, and he sees a drop for the Crimson Tide coming, such that they slot in behind Tennessee like many have called for among the media and talking heads the last two weeks.
ESPN’s Greg McElroy predicts Tennessee to jump ahead of Alabama in Tuesday’s College Football Playoff rankings
McElroy says that, if the committee applies it’s own logic, that Tennessee will stay at No. 8, Indiana will jump them to No. 7, and Alabama will fall to No. 9.
“At eight, it would be Tennessee at eight and two. Two ranked wins, including a 16-point win over a team that the committee currently has ranked third. At nine, it would be Bama. Eight and two, three ranked wins and a road win at LSU.
“But it’s ninth for the same reason Indiana dropped a few weeks ago. And Tennessee beat them head-to-head, and that would be factored in if they somehow got into the same pod. And this is the one place where the committee’s precedent — are they actually going to apply it? I don’t know. I’m just curious if they will.”
Now, this is in the analysis and rankings of what McElroy says the rankings WILL be on Tuesday. In his rankings of what they SHOULD be, he has Bama at four and Tennessee at nine (McElroy’s segment here is a little bit confusing because he wraps up the “should be” rankings by saying he thinks that’s what the committee will do before going into the “will be” rankings by saying if the committee applies its own logic.)
Will the CFP committee follow their own history/logic on Tuesday? Probably not
Really, as McElroy notes, it comes down to whether the committee is willing to follow its own logic for Alabama. Are they willing to dock them for their resume taking an undeniable hit over the weekend with their best wins all falling? With the high ranking that the committee has handed the Crimson Tide, I find it hard to believe.
As such, until the committee shows they don’t favor Tennessee’s chief rival, I think it’s likely more of the same with Tennessee looking up in the rankings at the team they handled convincingly last month.

