Bengals RT Amarius Mims has made Steelers EDGE T.J. Watt’s 2026 season worse all by himself

The Cincinnati Bengals know all too well about the damage Pittsburgh Steelers EDGE TJ Watt can create. Bengals right tackle Amarius Mims made sure he was a non-factor in both of their meetings this season.

John Sheeran — Cincinnati Bengals News Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Amarius Mims
Nov 15, 2026; Cincinnati, Ohio, USA; Cincinnati Bengals offensive tackle Amarius Mims (71) battles with Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker T.J. Watt (90) during the fourth quarter at Paycor Stadium. Katie Stratman-Imagn Images

The Cincinnati Bengals know all too well about the damage Pittsburgh Steelers EDGE T.J. Watt can create. Watt has been one of the best defensive players in all the football for the past decade. He’s had some of his best moments against the Bengals in his 10-year career.

He added zero positive moments in his two matchups against Cincinnati this season. Like a lot of things this year, the Bengals have right tackle Amarius Mims to thank for that.

Cincy’s 38-18 victory over the Steelers on “Sunday Night Football” featured yet another master class of pass protection from Mims. For the second time this year, the 24-year-old (who was 23 in the first game at Pittsburgh) completely shut out Watt as a pass rusher. Even in 2026, a few years removed from the peak of Watt’s dominance in this game, that’s a feat that shouldn’t go unnoticed.

T.J. Watt’s worst games in 2026 have been against Amarius Mims

According to Next Gen Stats, Mims had 45 pass blocking reps against Watt in their two head-to-head meetings this year and allowed zero pressures. He received help in the form of a chip block just 10 times, with it only happening twice on Sunday night.

The tape shows everything crystal clear. Watt simply could not get through Mims, which is also been the story for every EDGE who has gone up against the Bengals’ RT.

The story of Watt’s season hasn’t been as glamorous, at least relative to his reputation. He is still tied for seventh in sacks with 7.5, but his pass rush win rate (9%) ranks 52nd among starting EDGEs, according to Pro Football Focus. He has 25 pressures (ranks 35th among starters) to go with his 7.5 sacks, and they’ve come in the seven non-Bengals games this year.

An average Watt game this year against any team aside from the Bengals features between three and four pressures and a sack. He may not be winning a high rate of his rushes, but he wins, he’s impacting the QB to some level.

Watt’s lack of production against Mims is so striking that his season looks demonstrably worse just from him participating in Pittsburgh’s two contests against Cincy.

T.J. Watt in seven non-Bengals games through Week 10

League-wide rankings in parentheses

  • 7.5 sacks (fifth)
  • 25 pressures (17th)
  • 10.2% pass rush win rate (49th)

Mims adds another feather in his cap

There were still real expectations for Watt to do something, anything, against Mims on Sunday night. There’s no need to pretend everyone has moved past him being an effective rusher, even if he looks past his prime. He’s been capable of getting to the QB in every single game he hasn’t had to face Mims.

He simply went 0/2. Or 0/45. However you want to look at it.

Mims is in the midst of an incredible season of pass protection. He has allowed the second-lowest pressure rate (1.6%) out of all starting tackles behind Denver Broncos left tackle Garrett Bolles (1.5%). He has the sixth-highest pass block win rate (94.5%) and the seventh-highest win rate while blocking on an island (94.2%), according to Pro Football Focus.

Above all else, he has not allowed Cincinnati quarterback Joe Burrow to be sacked in a true passing situation. It used to be a biannual fear for Burrow to see Watt barreling towards him with bad intentions.

Fear no more when No. 71 is in his way.

Play A to Z Daily Games