ESPN analyst drops a surprising harsh take on the New Orleans Saints’ future on offense

Things aren’t exactly going to plan for the New Orleans Saints this season. But this take from ESPN analyst Ben Solak goes beyond tough love.

Kyle Crabbs — NFL National Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Tyler Shough
Sep 20, 2026; Baltimore, Maryland, USA; New Orleans Saints quarterback Tyler Shough (6) throws in the second quarter against the Baltimore Ravens at M&T Bank Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jamie Sabau-Imagn Images

The New Orleans Saints‘ season has been a disappointment through the first half of the season, to say the least.

New Orleans entered this season with hopes of regathering themselves as a legitimate playoff team — not just a participant in the NFC South’s annual competition for a playoff berth. And while New Orleans may ultimately punch their ticket to the postseason when it is all said and done, it doesn’t look the way anyone had hoped. Things have been rocky.

So much so that one ESPN analyst thinks the Saints may be barking up the wrong tree with their ongoing commitment to quarterback Tyler Shough.

ESPN analyst Benjamin Solak thinks the New Orleans Saints need to replace QB Tyler Shough this offseason

Tyler Shough
Sep 20, 2026; Baltimore, Maryland, USA; New Orleans Saints quarterback Tyler Shough. Mandatory Credit: Jamie Sabau-Imagn Images

“Shough will likely get a longer grace period than (Michael) Penix might, seeing as he’s only a second-year pro, but he is 27 and it’s hard to imagine him improving much at this age. Of all the things difficult to teach a quarterback, aggression is perhaps the most challenging. Unless I see Shough decide to push the ball into tighter windows down the stretch of 2026, I’ll wonder just how committed the Saints are to a second-round pick — remember, he doesn’t have a first-round pedigree! — as the unquestioned starter…The quarterback hurt the offense in the must-win against the Panthers and has kept their passing game far too meek through 10 weeks of this season. Something needs to change, fast.”

— ESPN analyst Benjamin Solak on New Orleans Saints quarterback Tyler Shough

Has Shough taken a meaningful step forward in 2026? Not exactly. His efficiency numbers are generally down and his play has, as Solak points out, pulled back on aggressiveness. But as Solak also points out, Shough is quarterbacking a shell of an offense that features next to zero threat on the ground and has dealt with instability along the offensive line for much of this season.

Pump the brakes!

I can understand casting some doubt on the trajectory. But replacing him altogether? That feels like a bridge too far gone. The Saints should be plenty focused on fixing their offense. That can hopefully happen with names like Jordyn Tyson and Kelvin Banks Jr. back in the fray. But no matter how this season ends, the Saints will need to take a long, hard look in the mirror.

Solak is right that things need to change fast. But the entire operation has been flawed and New Orleans’ punchless running game is a nice place to point the finger first. The Saints are a nice reminder that spamming the passing game and tilting the scales without balance in your play call is detrimental to the cause. The Saints lack the threat of a run game and don’t even bother to pretend running the ball, either. New Orleans currently ranks 25th in the league in play action rate — and Shough throws the ball on average more than 38 times a game.

I’d be surprised if the Saints settled this offseason on their second-year quarterback as the root of the problem. He’s a mature player, yes. But his offense isn’t offering him the amenities to have easy button throws to target, nor a run game to lean on. Both are variables that need to be solved before we can assume Shough is to blame.

Play A to Z Daily Games