‘Stop assuming’ – On3’s Andy Staples has the best take yet on something the CFP committee is doing with Tennessee, and he’s probably right

The Tennessee Volunteers fell to No. 9 in this week’s College Football Playoff rankings despite a gutsy win over the Texas A&M Aggies in College Station.

Zach Ragan — Tennessee Volunteers News Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Tennessee Vols football
Caitie McMekin/News Sentinel / USA TODAY NETWORK

No one is quite sure why Alabama is ranked at No. 3 and Tennessee is at No. 9 in this week’s College Football Playoff rankings.

The two teams have nearly identical resumes, they both have two losses, and the Vols beat Alabama by 16 points a month ago.

(No one knows why Texas, which beat Tennessee, is ranked below Alabama, either.)

On3’s Andy Staples shared his take on the controversial ranking on Wednesday during an appearance on McElroy and Cubelic in the Morning.

And his take makes a lot of sense.

Staples thinks the College Football Playoff committee keeps assuming that Tennessee is going to lose again instead of ranking them fairly based on what they’ve accomplished so far this season.

“I think they think Alabama has a better offense and a more realistic chance of doing something in the tournament,” said Staples. “And they feel like Tennessee’s offense probably isn’t good enough to go deep in the tournament. But the thing is, I feel like they’re falling into the same trap that they fell in last year with Miami and Notre Dame, where they kept Miami below Notre Dame — even though Miami should have been above Notre Dame because Miami had lost to Louisville and SMU. And they were just assuming Miami was going to lose again.

“They’re assuming Tennessee is going to lose again because they’re like, ‘I don’t know if this offense is any good.’ Well, stop assuming. If they lose to LSU, you can drop them all you want. But stop assuming — wait until they actually lose. If they keep winning, they have the same resume as Alabama, and they beat them.”

It does feel like that’s part of what’s going on, and that shouldn’t be the case. The committee can’t rank teams based on what they think is going to happen in the tournament. No one has a clue how the postseason will play out. The committee has no business ranking anyone based on who they think has the best chance to win in the tournament. They need to rank teams based on what’s actually happened to this point in this season.

And what’s happened to this point in the season is that Tennessee has the same resume and record as Alabama and a head-to-head win over the Crimson Tide. There’s no reason there should be six spots between the two teams.

Play A to Z Daily Games