Debating Alabama vs. Tennessee CFP Rankings: Who’s right and who’s wrong after the latest batch on Tuesday night

Both sides are making an argument.

Add as preferred source on Google
Tennessee defensive back TJ Metcalf (1) jumps in front of Alabama quarterback Keelon Russell (12) during a football game between Tennessee and Alabama at Neyland Stadium in Knoxville, Tenn., on Oct. 17, 2026.
Tennessee defensive back TJ Metcalf (1) jumps in front of Alabama quarterback Keelon Russell (12) during a football game between Tennessee and Alabama at Neyland Stadium in Knoxville, Tenn., on Oct. 17, 2026.

The Alabama Crimson Tide remained at 3 in the latest CFP rankings on Tuesday night, and it’s safe to say that has rubbed a lot of people the wrong way. The foremost being Tennessee Vols fans. The fans of the Orange and White have been screaming about “injustices” for weeks, but after last weekend’s results, that has set the fire ablaze.

So today, I am going to present the side of Alabama, while Tennessee is defended from our panel’s live reaction during Tuesday night. Let’s dive in.

Alabama’s case: SOS and BCS rankings

For me, this is a pretty cut-and-dry case for Alabama being ranked ahead of the Vols. For one, Alabama boasts a better strength of schedule by a wide margin. Per ESPN’s Football Power Index strength of schedule, the Tide sit at No. 6, compared to the Vols at No. 23. For the TeamRankings schedule strength, Alabama sits at No.2 while Tennessee is No. 12. But if that objective measure isn’t enough, how about we compare the BCS ranking to the committee.

As you can see in the post from BCS Knows How, Alabama does take a drop to 7 compared to the CFP committee’s ranking at 3, but guess what, they’re still 2 spots ahead of the Tennessee Vols, and they remain ahead of the Longhorns as well. Sure, Tennessee has the head-to-head, but they also lost to a 6-4 South Carolina team that Alabama thumped.

No subjectivity, no bias, just numbers to show why Alabama is rightfully ranked ahead of the Vols. Now for their side of the story.

Why the Vols should be ranked ahead of Alabama

“Alabama deserves zero credit for what happened at Vanderbilt. This is not Diego Pavia’s Vandy from the last two seasons. Vanderbilt is a bad football team, and Alabama played like it knew that.

The Commodores led 3-0 until the Tide finally found the end zone late in the second quarter. Alabama won 21-6. Lottie freaking da.

Then there was the gamesmanship about who would play quarterback, which felt like messaging aimed squarely at the committee. That’s the frustrating part. Everything Alabama does seems pitched toward that room, and the room keeps drinking it.

Now look at Tennessee’s week. The Vols faced a Texas A&M roster that likely costs about twice as much as Vanderbilt’s, in a stadium with far more Aggies fans than Vanderbilt fans showed up to watch Alabama. It was a home game for the Tide.

Texas A&M has real NFL talent. The Aggies took South Carolina to the brink in Columbia a week earlier. Tennessee held them to seven points.

Go look at Texas A&M’s drive chart. In the second half, the Aggies had one drive longer than five plays, and that was their touchdown drive.

Outside of that, it reads like this: punt, turnover on downs, interception, interception, punt, punt, punt, punt, punt.

The Vols have a national championship-level defense, and it shows up every week regardless of the opponent.

How many touchdown passes has Tennessee’s defense allowed through 10 games?

Four. You don’t need a second hand to count them. You don’t even need your thumb.

Then there’s the head-to-head. Tennessee beat Alabama by 16 points, and the Tide managed one real scoring drive in that game, which came after a turnover by the Vols’ offense.”

The bottom line

We have two weekends of games left before championship weekend and ultimately selection Sunday. All either team should be worried about is winning the game in front of them. After that, let the chips fall where they may.

Play A to Z Daily Games