NFL insider reveals Bengals are learning their lesson after swinging and missing at the trade deadline

The Cincinnati Bengals want to make sure they never have to back out of a trade ever again due to the compensatory pick formula, or anything potential barrier to getting a deal done.

John Sheeran — Cincinnati Bengals News Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Duke Tobin
Cincinnati Bengals director of player personnel Duke Tobin takes questions from the press during the annual season kickoff media day event at Paycor Stadium in downtown Cincinnati on Monday, July 27, 2026. Sam Greene/The Enquirer / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

The Cincinnati Bengals want to make sure they never have to back out of a trade ever again due to the compensatory pick formula, or anything potential barrier to getting a deal done.

ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler reports Cincinnati “will likely evaluate” its process regarding vetting trades after having to back out of trading for Philadelphia Eagles EDGE Arnold Ebiketie.

A high-ranking Bengals source acknowledged the team will likely evaluate how it vets future trades in light of the nixed Arnold Ebiketie deal. Mainly, the team can accelerate the process of confirming details such as how a trade affects the compensatory pick formula. The Bengals ‘work to confirm everything’ on all trades, the source said, including calling the NFL management council for clarity. Typically they do that late in the process and there’s no issue. But in this case, they found out about the comp-pick issue after the deal was agreed to with Philadelphia. ‘We can try to accelerate the process of determining how contracts are treated [by the league],’ the source said.

Jeremy Fowler

ESPN senior NFL national reporter

Bengals nullified their own trade deadline move

The Bengals didn’t want to sit on their hands during the NFL trade deadline last week. They agreed to a deal that would give them Ebiketie in exchange for their sixth-round pick in the 2027 NFL Draft.

As everyone knows by now, Cincinnati didn’t realize the deal would likely erase a third-round compensatory pick coming its way this March and backed out of the deal. The Bengals are expected to net a pick which will land somewhere between No. 97 and No. 99 in the draft order because they lost more qualifying free agents than they gained this year including Trey Hendrickson, who signed a contract worth $28 million per year. Hendrickson’s contract was large enough to project one of the earliest comp picks going to Cincy next year.

Trading for Ebiketie would take it away the potential comp pick he was a free agent signing by the Eagles this year and would then count the formula for the Bengals. They didn’t know this when the trade was agreed upon and reported to league insiders.

Now, after the entire NFL world saw their ignorance play out in real time, they appear focused on ensuring nothing like this ever happens again.

We can try to accelerate the process of determining how contracts are treated [by the league].

Hign-ranking bengals source

Via Jeremy Fowler

Step in the right direction

Cincinnati still had time to conduct a trade after the Ebiketie deal fell through. It’s fair to assume the club was unsure about whether or not trading for other players would also take away the comp pick it expects to have in next year’s draft.

The Bengals ran into an information problem at the end of the day, or lack thereof. Gathering the vital info when deals come together and fall apart in the blink of an eye is crucial. The ability to pivot when things fall apart is just as important. That requires a better and more informed process.

It sounds like Cincinnati understands what its problem was last week, and the front office will have plenty of time to strategize and implement a new process when the window for trades opens again in the offseason.

Play A to Z Daily Games