College Football Playoff rankings keep Alabama at No. 3, and the committee’s logic makes less sense every single week

The Crimson Tide’s spot in the latest rankings raises a question the committee doesn’t seem interested in answering.

Joe DeLeone — NFL & College Football News Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Oct 17, 2026; Knoxville, Tennessee, USA; Alabama Crimson Tide head coach Kalen DeBoer reacts during the first half against the Tennessee Volunteers at Neyland Stadium. Randy Sartin-Imagn Images

The College Football Playoff committee released its latest rankings, and Alabama is still sitting at No. 3. And I still have no idea why the committee loves Alabama so much.

The Crimson Tide’s resume took a hit after last weekend, and the committee rewarded them by keeping them right where they were. Alabama stayed ahead of Miami, Notre Dame, and Indiana, all of whom have better records. It also stayed ahead of Tennessee, who own a head-to-head win over the Crimson Tide.

Alabama’s losses aren’t the problem

Alabama does have quality losses. In fact, the Crimson Tide have the best losses of any team in the playoff field. 

However, the committee keeps acting like head-to-head results don’t matter, and that adds an absurd layer to this whole thing. Tennessee beat Alabama on the field, yet the Volunteers sit behind the team they beat. As I stated previously, I find it hard to believe that holds up to any real scrutiny.

Let’s set the losses and the head-to-head debate aside for a moment. They aren’t the biggest flaw in Alabama’s resume.

What is Alabama’s best win?

The real issue for the Crimson Tide is the lack of a signature victory. When you lay out the schedule, where is the win that justifies a No. 3 ranking?

Is it the win over an inconsistent South Carolina team? The Gamecocks have been hard to figure out all season, and beating them doesn’t move the needle.

Is it blowing the doors off a banged-up Mississippi State team? Ironically, ESPN put that game on the graphic during the CFP reveal recently, as if it were a resume-defining moment. It wasn’t.

Is it the win over LSU? The Tigers are no longer ranked, so that victory has lost a lot of its shine.

Or an early-season win over Kentucky that is starting to skid down the stretch?

None of those results scream top-3 team. Alabama has been living off its name, and the strength of its losses, and the committee keeps signing off on it.

Indiana deserves better from the committee

The most frustrating part of this update is how the committee continues to treat Indiana. Last week, the Hoosiers essentially got penalized for having a bye week. They didn’t play, and they slid behind teams that did.

This week, Indiana went out and earned a ranked win over USC. That’s exactly the kind of victory the committee claims to value. Meanwhile, Alabama messed around with Vanderbilt and didn’t do anything to strengthen its case.

To be fair, Indiana’s schedule isn’t as tough as Alabama’s. Nobody is arguing otherwise. Still, the Hoosiers have a better record and a ranked victory to show for their work, and they remain behind the Crimson Tide. That makes zero sense.

The committee can’t penalize Indiana for not playing one week and then ignore the Hoosiers when they win a meaningful game the next. Consistency should matter in this process, and right now, it’s nowhere to be found.

Alabama keeps getting the benefit of the doubt, while teams with better records, better recent results, and in Tennessee’s case, a head-to-head win over the Crimson Tide keep getting left behind. Hopefully, the committee starts evaluating what teams have actually accomplished on the field because the current approach is turning these rankings into a popularity contest.

Play A to Z Daily Games