Giants’ 4 midseason offensive awards include J.J. McCarthy, a frustrating disappointment, and an MVP in elite company
The New York Giants have outperformed expectations through nine games. Here’s who has shown up on offense and who hasn’t.
The New York Giants are past the halfway point of the season, and before they face the Jacksonville Jaguars, it’s the perfect time to hand out midseason offensive awards. The Giants have outperformed expectations, but that doesn’t tell the whole story of who has carried this team and who has held it back.
Biggest surprise: J.J. McCarthy
This one is easy. When quarterback Jaxson Dart went down with his injury, the outlook for New York was bleak. Dart looked ready to take a huge step after the way he played against the Dallas Cowboys, and the coaching staff had built a system around him that was working. Then Jameis Winston stepped in and was all over the place.
I was one of the few people who was optimistic about McCarthy, and I was in favor of the trade. My thinking was simple. He’s similar enough to Dart physically that the Giants could get back to a run-heavy system that uses the quarterback as a rusher. Winston didn’t fit that mold.
Still, I didn’t expect McCarthy to play this well. He has completed 63.5% of his passes for 915 yards in three starts and five appearances. He has two touchdown passes, two interceptions, 8.8 yards per attempt, and a 90 passer rating. He has also added 85 rushing yards on 15 carries.
There’s room for more. I’d like to see the Giants use him more as a runner, because the ground game needs it. He also needs to attack the end zone more often. Two touchdown passes in three starts isn’t disappointing, but it’s lighter than you’d hope for.
He has played well enough that we can legitimately debate which quarterback to keep. I believe New York should keep Dart and use McCarthy’s momentum to trade him, because his value will be higher than Dart’s. Most importantly, Dart is a vocal leader. Trading him away could hurt a culture that has grown over the course of the season.
Biggest disappointment: Jon Runyan and John Michael Schmitz
The offensive line has been up and down. There have been strong games and weak ones, and the interior is the biggest problem.
Runyan has clearly been the worst offensive lineman in the group. He’s replaceable, but the Giants just gave him an extension, which complicates things. It was a bad decision to extend him when he hadn’t done much to earn it.
Schmitz getting benched for Bryan Hudson early in the year is also frustrating. The hope was that he would step up and improve, and it simply hasn’t happened. Hudson has been fine, but it looks like the Giants could be shopping for a new center this offseason, either in free agency or the draft.
Best rookie: Francis Mauigoa
Malachi Fields received consideration, but his production hasn’t jumped off the page. Mauigoa has had moments where he has looked excellent, along with spurts of frustration. He has allowed 16 pressures and two sacks on 367 pass-rush snaps, which is a solid rookie season.
He hasn’t fully built off his strong start, and there’s still meat left on the bone. He’s a rookie, though, and not everything needs to happen overnight. It doesn’t help that the rest of the interior has struggled. Runyan’s problems force Mauigoa to be the best of the group, which is a lot of pressure on a rookie’s shoulders.
Offensive MVP: Isaiah Likely
I nearly went with Malik Nabers, and I considered a dual award. However, Nabers’ iffy stretch recently made it easier to pick Likely.
He has done everything well as a tight end. He’s been fine as a blocker, his hands have been incredibly reliable, and he’s been fantastic after the catch, making defenders miss and creating long gains like he did against the Commanders. He has also been tremendous in the red zone, turning five of his 11 targets inside the 20 into touchdowns.
Likely has 55 catches on 80 targets for 575 yards and seven touchdowns. He leads all tight ends in touchdown catches and ranks third in receiving yards behind Brock Bowers and Trey McBride. That is elite company. He’s pacing for a potential 1,000-yard season, and even if he levels off around 900 yards with 10 or 11 touchdowns, that’s one of the best tight end seasons in the league.
New York needed Likely to step up early while Nabers came back from his injury. He did, and now both are creating splash plays through the air.

