Giants’ midseason defensive awards crown a rookie star as MVP while a former first-round pick lands as the biggest disappointment
The New York Giants’ defense looks nothing like it did in September. Here’s who deserves the credit and who has come up short.
The New York Giants’ defense has completely changed its identity since the start of the season, and it’s time to hand out midseason awards.
Defensive MVP and best rookie: Arvell Reese
Rookie linebacker Arvell Reese has clearly been the best piece of New York’s defense. You could make a case for safety Jevon Holland, and Abdul Carter has had some strong stretches. However, Reese is the glue holding everything together, and he elevates everybody around him.
Through nine starts, Reese has 81 tackles, eight tackles for loss, 4.5 sacks, five quarterback hits, four passes defended, an interception, and a forced fumble. He leads the Giants in both tackles and sacks, which is absurd for an off-ball linebacker. He also recorded a 2.29-second strip sack against the Eagles, the fastest in the NFL this season, when he went untouched and blew up Joe Milton. Additionally, his two sacks from the inside linebacker spot make him the only player to do that this season.
When the Giants drafted Reese in the 2026 NFL draft, I had some pause. He has great off-ball instincts, but what makes him special is his burst and bend as a blitzer. Interior offensive linemen can’t keep up with him. That’s why he was so dominant at Ohio State, where Matt Patricia sent him from the interior and left guards and centers panicked trying to block him.
With Kayvon Thibodeaux, Carter, and Brian Burns on the roster, it wasn’t clear whether New York would commit to sending extra heat and activating Reese’s best asset. Early in the season, it didn’t. The Giants played on their heels and weren’t a heavy blitzing team.
Once Burns went down, the identity shifted to an attacking, come-at-your-head approach, and it changed everything. If the Giants carry that approach into next season once Burns returns, this defense could be extremely dangerous.
Without Reese, this could have been a total defensive failure. It also shows how poor a play caller Shane Bowen was. He had a healthier group and Burns coming off a Defensive Player of the Year-caliber season, yet he couldn’t get more out of that unit.
Biggest surprises: Deonte Banks and Jevon Holland
I couldn’t pick between two players here.
Cornerback Deonte Banks has looked like a completely different player. In seven starts, he has 27 tackles, 11 passes defended (tied for third in the NFL), and a 98-yard pick-six that helped beat Arizona. He’s finally playing in a scheme that knows how to use his tools, putting him in physical one-on-one situations.
He has had frustrating moments, including penalties against the Commanders, but his disruption at the catch point has been remarkable. Banks is allowing only 3.1 yards of separation, the second fewest among qualified corners. He hasn’t been a top-5 corner, but he has been top 15.
Banks being a surprise comes from the fact that nobody expected anything from him this season. I even talked about him potentially getting cut. Instead, he responded to adversity and stepped up. Hopefully, New York does everything possible to bring him back, because it would be disappointing to watch him finally figure it out and then leave.
Banks and Newsome have formed a strong tandem. If Colton Hood develops, the Giants might not need to draft another corner. This was supposed to be one of the worst cornerback rooms in the NFL, and it has been a breath of fresh air instead.
Holland was also disappointing last season and didn’t feel worth his free-agent price tag. This season, he has 37 tackles, six pass breakups, four interceptions (tied for third in the league), two forced fumbles, and a fumble recovery. Opposing quarterbacks have a 45.1 passer rating when targeting him. His transformation into a turnover machine has made this defense far more dangerous.
Biggest disappointment: Kayvon Thibodeaux
This one was hard to pick, but Thibodeaux is the choice. I hadn’t fully registered it until digging into the numbers, but he has zero sacks.
With Burns out, you would expect Thibodeaux to step up and pile up production. That hasn’t happened. He has three quarterback hits and 18 pressures on 221 pass rush snaps, good for an 8.1% pressure rate. His 9.3% pass rush win rate is the second lowest of his career.
He had every chance to earn a big contract. I still believe not trading him was one of the Giants’ biggest mistakes, even if losing Burns meant they needed him. Considering how he’s played, New York likely won’t re-sign him, and he will probably hit free agency. If that happens, the Giants get no return for a former first-round pick. Calling his season a disappointment is an understatement.
Hopefully, the Giants keep leaning into their aggressive identity with Reese leading the way, because this defense has finally found something worth building around.

