Miami Hurricanes QB Darian Mensah shut out of a major award for a ridiculous reason that needs to be exposed in modern college football era
The Canes’ star QB will likely be a Heisman Trophy finalist, but he won’t for another notable award.
Miami Hurricanes QB Darian Mensah should be seated in the front row in the second weekend of December when the Heisman Trophy finalists are announced. It’s been that kind of season for the Canes’ star QB.
Mensah has been arguably the best quarterback in the nation this year, and the stats back that up. He’s completed an FBS-best 76.3% of his throws for 3076 yards with 29 touchdowns to just two interceptions. And keep in mind, he didn’t play in the fourth quarter for a number of Miami’s early season wins.
Miami Hurricanes QB Darian Mensah not among finalists for Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award
But his omission from one of the top individual awards on Friday left a ton of people scratching their heads. The five finalists for the Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award were announced, and Mensah was nowhere to be seen.
Mensah didn’t qualify because he’s played for more than two schools, and that’s ridiculous in the modern college football era
The reason for his omission becomes clear when you look at the list of criteria for the award. Among them include one that requires players to have played for no more than two programs.

I don’t think that, in today’s transfer portal/NIL world, limiting participants based upon the number of times they’ve transferred should be a criteria. Yes, the award claims to look for “commitment and loyalty” to teammates, university, etc. And if that’s the prerogative they want to take to cut off the best quarterbacks, which also omits Wake Forest standout Gio Lopez, then more power to them.
But to the extent the award is considered by Heisman Trophy voters or voters on other awards, like the Maxwell Trophy, then the reason for their omission had better damned well be crystal clear. The Unitas award believes multiple portal trips makes them unfit for their award. Portal trips have not a thing to do with how well a player performs and lifts up the school.
Cam Ward, Carson Beck, and Darian Mensah have proven that, for a player, you can find a better situation in the transfer portal and get the best out of yourself in the process while making your teammates and new program better. That’s a good thing. And if we’re going to not recognize that with one award, that award had better not influence other awards that Mensah, Lopez, and other players in similar situations undoubtedly deserve strong consideration for.

