Daniel Jones’ Release Exposes the Colts’ Dysfunction, and Indianapolis Has Much Bigger Problems to Solve

The Indianapolis Colts just moved on from Daniel Jones, but why now? There are a lot of unanswered questions to evaluate for this franchise.

Add as preferred source on Google
Nov 1, 2026; Jacksonville, Florida, USA; Indianapolis Colts quarterback Daniel Jones (17) talsk to head coach Shane Steichen during the first quarter against the Jacksonville Jaguars at EverBank Stadium.
Nov 1, 2026; Jacksonville, Florida, USA; Indianapolis Colts quarterback Daniel Jones (17) talsk to head coach Shane Steichen during the first quarter against the Jacksonville Jaguars at EverBank Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Travis Register-Imagn Images

The Indianapolis Colts have officially moved on from Daniel Jones, but the decision to release their starting quarterback might be more revealing than the quarterback’s disappointing performance ever was.

Indianapolis released Jones on Friday, less than 24 hours after a 26-3 loss to the Houston Texans dropped the team to 3-8. The timing was particularly strange. The NFL trade deadline had passed roughly 10 days earlier, leaving the Colts with no opportunity to recoup draft capital for a quarterback who had been struggling for much of the season.

Jones’ departure comes just weeks after Indianapolis parted ways with general manager Chris Ballard. With the quarterback gone and the front office searching for new leadership, the Colts are suddenly staring at an offseason filled with questions.

Head coach Shane Steichen’s future is uncertain, the quarterback position is back to square one, and the organization doesn’t have a first-round pick in the 2027 NFL Draft.

There is a financial explanation for some of these decisions, but the bigger picture is difficult to ignore. Indianapolis looks like a franchise without a clear direction, and the Jones situation is another example of how poorly things have gone over the last several months.

The Daniel Jones experiment was a failure, but the timing is even more concerning

There wasn’t much left to debate about Jones’ performance in Indianapolis. He threw seven touchdown passes and 13 interceptions through 11 games, and Thursday night’s performance against Houston was arguably the lowest point of his season.

Jones completed just 9-of-21 passes in the 26-3 loss, looking completely overwhelmed against a Houston defense that has given opposing quarterbacks problems throughout the season.

The supporting cast deserves some consideration. Alec Pierce, one of Jones’ most important weapons and a player whose connection with the quarterback helped influence the Colts’ offseason decision-making, has been sidelined with an ankle injury. Outside of running back Jonathan Taylor, Indianapolis hasn’t consistently surrounded its quarterback with enough playmakers.

Still, that doesn’t excuse what Jones put on the field.

Indianapolis gave him a two-year, $88 million contract this offseason while he was recovering from a torn Achilles. The organization was betting that the version of Jones it saw during his brief stretch during the first half of 2025 could be replicated over a full season.

That bet didn’t come close to paying off.

The more interesting question is why the Colts waited until November 20 to make this decision.

There were reportedly teams interested in Jones ahead of the trade deadline, with the Minnesota Vikings and Baltimore Ravens among the organizations connected to him. NFL insider Jordan Schultz reported that Indianapolis had decided against trading Jones because the team believed it had already committed too much money to him through his signing bonus.

That explanation makes the decision to release him 10 days after the deadline even more difficult to understand.

If the Colts were comfortable moving on from Jones less than two weeks later, why wasn’t that possibility explored before the deadline? Even a late-round draft pick would have been better than receiving nothing in return for a quarterback who clearly wasn’t part of the organization’s future.

There is one financial component worth understanding. Jones had $10.51 million of his $33.49 million base salary for 2027 scheduled to become guaranteed for injury, with the relevant vesting date in March 2027. Releasing him now protects Indianapolis from that potential obligation.

That is meaningful money, particularly for a franchise that needs to rebuild its roster. However, saving approximately $10.5 million doesn’t erase the fact that Indianapolis potentially passed on an opportunity to acquire draft capital for a player it ultimately released anyway.

The decision also raises questions about the original contract. Jones was coming off a significant injury, and the Colts had only a relatively small sample of encouraging football from his time in Minnesota. Giving him that kind of financial commitment was a substantial gamble.

It failed, and the organization is now paying for it.

Anthony Richardson is getting another opportunity, but don’t mistake it for a long-term commitment

With Jones out of the picture, Indianapolis has handed the quarterback position back to Anthony Richardson.

That is an interesting development, particularly considering how much of the season Richardson spent watching from the sidelines. He now has an opportunity to put additional game film on display, but I wouldn’t necessarily view this as a last-ditch audition to become the Colts’ starting quarterback in 2027.

In fact, I think the bigger benefit could come from what Richardson shows the rest of the NFL.

There are still teams around the league that could view him as a developmental quarterback worth taking a chance on. His athletic ability and physical tools remain intriguing, even if the consistency and accuracy haven’t developed the way Indianapolis hoped.

Every additional start gives potential suitors more information.

The same logic applies to Riley Leonard, who remains another young quarterback Indianapolis can evaluate. Getting meaningful game experience for either player is more valuable than spending the final weeks of a lost season with Jones under center.

I also suspect Steichen and the coaching staff already have a pretty good idea of what they think about Richardson and Leonard. They have watched both players in practice, meetings, and the day-to-day operation of the building. These final games aren’t necessarily going to reveal something completely new.

However, they can help determine whether either player deserves a spot in next year’s quarterback room.

I don’t believe either Richardson or Leonard should automatically be viewed as Indianapolis’ starting quarterback next season. If the Colts are serious about fixing this position, they need to explore every available option rather than convince themselves that an answer already exists on the roster.

The Colts have a quarterback problem with no obvious solution

The timing of Jones’ release makes the upcoming offseason even more complicated.

Indianapolis doesn’t own its first-round selection in the 2027 NFL Draft, which significantly limits its ability to address the quarterback position through the draft. The free-agent market also isn’t particularly appealing, and the Colts have too many roster holes to pretend they are one quarterback away from competing.

Even if Indianapolis manages to land a veteran starter, what exactly is that player walking into?

The offensive line gives the organization something to build around, and Jonathan Taylor remains an important piece. Beyond that, there are significant questions at wide receiver and on defense.

The Colts need another infusion of young talent before they can realistically expect to compete.

I actually think Indianapolis should consider a low-cost developmental quarterback rather than throwing significant money or draft capital at the position this offseason. Someone like Spencer Rattler could make sense as a reclamation project. He has enough developmental intrigue to warrant a look without requiring the Colts to make another massive financial commitment.

Will Levis could also be worth monitoring, depending on his availability and the circumstances surrounding his situation with the New York Jets.

The point is that Indianapolis needs to find a quarterback who can be evaluated without sacrificing the resources necessary to rebuild the rest of the roster.

The Miami Dolphins’ approach with Malik Willis is an interesting model, although Indianapolis doesn’t necessarily have the same collection of draft capital to surround a developmental quarterback with young talent.

I would rather see the Colts take a step back, accumulate assets and build a more complete roster than force another quarterback decision before the infrastructure is ready.

Realistically, 2027 could be another rebuilding year. The franchise-level quarterback solution might not arrive until 2028.

Shane Steichen is now facing an impossible evaluation

Perhaps the biggest unanswered question in Indianapolis is what happens with Steichen.

The Colts have already moved on from Ballard and Jones, leaving the head coach as the most obvious remaining piece of the previous leadership structure.

There are legitimate arguments on both sides of his future.

Steichen is widely regarded as a quality offensive mind, and it is difficult to fairly evaluate a head coach when the quarterback position has been this unstable. Indianapolis doesn’t have much offensive talent outside of Taylor, and the situation has become increasingly difficult to navigate.

Tyler Warren is another example of how strange this season has become. After showing so much promise last year, the tight end has essentially disappeared from the offensive picture. There are reasons to believe the quarterback situation has played a significant role in that development.

At the same time, Steichen hasn’t been completely removed from the decisions that got Indianapolis here. The quarterback situation has been a disaster, and the organization has to take a hard look at the people responsible for putting this roster together.

The bigger issue is the timing of the organizational changes.

Indianapolis fired Ballard first and then moved on from Jones. If ownership ultimately intends to move on from Steichen, why not make all three decisions together?

There is a familiar NFL pattern that the Colts should be trying to avoid. A franchise hires a new general manager, allows the existing head coach to remain in place, and eventually watches the relationship deteriorate. The new general manager then fires the coach, forcing the organization to start another search.

Ideally, a new general manager and head coach arrive together with a shared vision for the roster.

That is particularly important in Indianapolis because the next general manager will have a massive rebuilding project ahead of him. There isn’t an established franchise quarterback, there isn’t a first-round pick in 2027, and several position groups need significant upgrades.

Would a top general manager candidate really want to inherit a head coach he didn’t hire?

That is the biggest argument against Steichen returning. If Indianapolis lands the candidate it wants, there is a reasonable possibility that person will want to select his own head coach.

Steichen could ultimately survive, but his future is now tied to an organizational decision that might have very little to do with his ability to coach football.

The Colts’ situation could become a major win for the New York Jets

There is another team that should be paying close attention to Indianapolis’ collapse: the New York Jets.

Because of the Colts’ draft-pick situation, New York owns a significant portion of the upside if Indianapolis continues losing.

The Colts’ first-round selection currently belongs to the Jets, and Indianapolis’ remaining schedule offers very little reason for optimism. The team has a matchup against the New York Giants before road games against the Philadelphia Eagles and Tennessee Titans.

I wouldn’t be surprised if Indianapolis loses all three.

That would be a disastrous finish for Colts fans, especially considering the organization doesn’t even get the benefit of its first-round selection. The Jets, meanwhile, could end up with three selections inside the top 13, including two inside the top five, depending on how the remaining games play out.

That is an incredible position for New York to be in.

For Indianapolis, the remaining schedule is more about gathering information than making a playoff push. Richardson can get his opportunity, Leonard could factor into the evaluation, and the organization can begin preparing for an offseason that will likely reshape the entire franchise.

Unfortunately, losing out doesn’t solve the Colts’ biggest problems. It simply makes the Jets’ draft position even better.

Indianapolis needs a complete reset, not another quick fix

Ultimately, Daniel Jones’ release is about much more than one quarterback who didn’t play well enough.

The Colts made a significant financial commitment to a player coming off a major injury, failed to get the production they expected, passed on a potential opportunity to trade him, and then released him shortly after the deadline.

At the same time, they fired their general manager and left the head coach’s future hanging in the balance.

There is a financial benefit to moving on from Jones now, and Indianapolis will at least have an opportunity to evaluate Richardson and Leonard over the final weeks. Those are positives, but they don’t change the larger reality.

The Colts don’t have a clear answer at quarterback, they don’t have a first-round pick in 2027, and the next general manager will inherit a roster with significant work ahead.

I don’t think Indianapolis should be trying to convince itself that it can fix everything in one offseason. The franchise needs to be honest about where it stands, identify the right leadership group, and start building a sustainable foundation.

The most important decision won’t be who starts at quarterback in Week 12. It will be who gets to make that decision next offseason.

Because if the Colts get the next general manager and head coach pairing wrong, Daniel Jones won’t be the last expensive mistake this franchise has to clean up.

Play A to Z Daily Games