‘I’m just still not convinced’ – ESPN insider slams Tennessee’s win over LSU and explains why Vols likely won’t be in the same ‘pod’ as Alabama in CFP rankings
Don’t expect the Tennessee Volunteers to get any respect from the College Football Playoff committee after their 27-13 win over the LSU Tigers.
If you thought Tennessee was going to get some respect after a 14 point win over LSU, well, I’ve got some bad news for you.
ESPN’s Heather Dinich, who is the most plugged-in reporter in the business when it comes to the College Football Playoff committee, completely discounted the Vols’ 27-13 win over the Tigers on Saturday.
“I’m just not still convinced,” said Dinich of the Vols. “And look, let’s realize here that beating LSU is beating an unranked five-loss team. … It’s not like they beat a top 25 team.”
It’s a ridiculous take from Dinich. Vols fans heard all week how LSU has the most talented roster in the nation, and that they’re a “dangerous team.” But because they’re not included in the top 25 it’s not a good win? This is the kind of nonsense you get from people like Dinich when they spend more time staring at spreadsheets and metrics than actually watching games.
Dinich is essentially the voice of the College Football Playoff committee, so this is probably how Tennessee’s win over LSU will be viewed in the room.
And that’s obviously not good for the Vols’ chances of making a significant jump in this week’s rankings.
Heather Dinich explains the pod system and why Tennessee likely won’t move above Alabama this week
There were six spots between Tennessee and Alabama in last week’s rankings despite the Vols having the better resume and owning a 16-point win over the Crimson Tide.
The committee says the two teams are in different “pods,” and that they can’t be compared because of that (it’s really incredible how dumb this committee has been).
Dinich explained that the committee groups teams in pods of three. And she thinks there will still be too many teams between Alabama and Tennessee this week to compare the two programs (which is asinine because Indiana and UCLA, two teams ranked above the Vols, both lost this week).
“They have to be in the grouping of the same three,” said Dinich. “Because you talk about the first three and you vote for them. You’ve got a no-brainer with Georgia and Utah, and then insert Texas or Alabama (behind them), and then you start to vote for the next ones.
“And then are they in that same pod where you can pull them up on the computer screen together? And I think it was interesting that (committee chairman) Hunter Yurachek said that beyond the top two teams last week, Georgia at one and Utah at two, the margin between those next couple of teams was razor thin. And when you’re talking about those next couple of teams, you’re talking about Notre Dame, Miami, and Texas. You’re not yet talking about Tennessee.”
We’ll see what the committee actually does on Tuesday night. But there’s no reason Alabama should be ranked above either Texas or Tennessee. The Crimson Tide’s best win is against a 7-4 Kentucky team. They have no top 10 wins, and they were dominated by Tennessee.
The Vols are a couple of plays away from being 11-0 right now (though I’ll admit Texas was the better team when they beat the Vols…the Longhorns deserved that win, but Tennessee was better than South Carolina in a fluky road loss).
Alabama can’t say the same, but the committee loves their logo and colors, and that’s apparently going to be hard for Tennessee to overcome.

