We accidentally solved the biggest issue with the College Football Playoff rankings with a system that everyone will agree needs to be implemented next year
It’s time to radically change the way the teams are selected for the College Football Playoff.
I think I may have accidentally fixed the College Football Playoff.
At this point, it’s clear that College Football Playoff rankings are deeply flawed — and it’s not entirely the committee’s fault (even though they’ve done a terrible job with the rankings) — it’s an impossible task.
Dozens of versions of the rankings would be fair and make sense. Fans are making legitimate arguments for their favorite teams every week, and plenty of them hold up. The committee is never going to get it exactly right because “exactly right” doesn’t exist.
There’s just too much subjectivity, no matter how many made-up metrics the committee cites. Brand bias will always be baked into the process because certain programs get the benefit of the doubt and others don’t.
Here’s what I think needs to happen: wins and losses should determine who gets in and who doesn’t (just like the NFL).
Each Power Four conference should get five automatic bids (when the playoff moves to 24 teams next year).
I know some people will immediately scream that it isn’t fair for the Big 12 to get five teams in while the SEC only gets five. It is what it is. In the NFL, a team with a losing record sometimes wins a division while a team with a much better record misses out on a wild card spot.
Giving every conference five bids would immediately bring some equality to the sport, and it might even create more parity. It would also give programs a clear definition of what they need to do to reach the playoff.
A team like Kansas State would know it has a real shot if it finishes in the top five of the Big 12.
How a 24-team College Football Playoff with automatic bids would work
The five automatic bids for each Power Four conference would account for 20 spots in a 24-team playoff. The other four spots would go to Group of Five teams.
At that point, we could do away with the weekly rankings and hold a selection show with a committee, just like college basketball does.
The bracket would be split into four pods (or regions), and the teams in each pod would be seeded 1 through 6. The top two seeds in each pod would get a bye. The first round, for example, would feature the No. 3 seed against the No. 6 seed.
More often than not, that No. 6 seed would be the Group of Five team (and the first two rounds of the tournament will be on campus).
Group of Five programs would know they’re going to get their shot, which gives them a reason to invest in their programs. I think that makes the sport healthier (I don’t know how those bids would be determined, but we can work that out later).
The seeding process is also where the SEC and Big Ten can bring their politicking back into play. They can argue strength of schedule to earn home playoff games, byes, and every other advantage that comes with a better seed.
Not everybody is going to get on board with this. I get it. But if you finish below fifth in your conference, whether you’re in the SEC or the Big 12, you don’t deserve a spot in the postseason tournament.
Finish in the top five of your conference and you’re in. (Yes, we’d have to figure out a way to make the tiebreakers work. There would also probably need to be a scheduling overhaul, like what the NFL uses, to make sure schedule strength within conferences is close to equal.)
Other fixes that college football should consider
The playoff format isn’t the only thing college football could fix. There are a few other changes would make a lot of ense.
One option would be a rule — which would need to be enforced by the CFP — that playoff teams can’t spend more than $70 million on their rosters. That would keep spending from getting totally out of hand in future years.
The schools that make the most money would still have the best chance to win, so that element wouldn’t disappear. But it would at least put a cap on how high the spending can go (it’ll just continue to get out of hand if there isn’t a cap).
I’m not a lawyer, so I don’t know exactly how this would work. But perhaps the players, the CFP, and the schools could set up a collective bargaining agreement and bring some structure to player contracts.
No tampering, either. If a program tampers, it’s no longer eligible to make the playoff (and the player isn’t eligible to compete in the playoff).
Everything has to be above board, just like it is in the NFL. Locking players into contracts and setting clear boundaries would help everyone involved.
This kind of structure would be better for the entire sport. Everyone would know exactly what they can and can’t do, everyone would know exactly where they stand, and college football would look more like the NFL than ever.
Just do it.

