NFL analysts call for an uncomfortably familiar blueprint as the Pittsburgh Steelers’ last ride with Aaron Rodgers creeps towards a close

Pittsburgh will say goodbye to QB Aaron Rodgers next spring. How should the Steelers go about finding their next signal caller?

Kyle Crabbs — NFL National Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Oct 25, 2026; Paris, FRA; Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Aaron Rodgers (8) looks to throw downfield New Orleans Saints during the third quarter at Stade de France Stadium.
Oct 25, 2026; Paris, FRA; Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Aaron Rodgers (8) looks to throw downfield New Orleans Saints during the third quarter at Stade de France Stadium. Kirby Lee-Imagn Images

The Pittsburgh Steelers are staring at another quarterback decision in 2027, but the 2027 NFL Draft may not hold the answers you’d hope. And young quarterbacks Will Howard and Drew Allar? They’d be glorified leaps of blind faith given their experience. The college quarterback pipeline is thin right now. Some of that is thanks to NIL. Some of that is a lack of sustained player development before these passers reach the league.

Prospects like C.J. Carr and Drew Mestemaker appear to be fine prospects — but they figure to not be in range for Pittsburgh thanks to yet another looming playoff appearance that has many questioning the ceiling. So what are the Steelers to do? On this week’s episode of 4th & Football, co-hosts Kyle Crabbs and Garret Greenlee kicked around a different approach for the Steelers. It’s a blueprint Pittsburgh has tried before, but with a twist. But if at first you don’t succeed…

The Pittsburgh Steelers should consider a cost-effective veteran quarterback when life after Aaron Rodgers comes around 

“I am all for cost-effective swings that provide potential upside for long-term solutions. Whether it’s Drew Lock, whether it’s Mac Jones, (like) what Miami did with Malik Willis this year. If you sign a quarterback in free agency, that is well worth the price of admission to potentially find a long-term starter at quarterback in my mind.”

— Kyle Crabbs, 4th & Football

A cost-effective swing at a veteran quarterback? It may feel like deja vu for Steelers fans. And for that reason, I understand any apprehension you may feel. The Rodgers signing was supposed to be a breakthrough but it has offered nothing but more of the same. But, for several reasons, avoiding scrambling for a quarterback in the rat race of the NFL Draft may offer Pittsburgh a better path.

The philosophy of targeting a veteran quarterback only works with the right kind of player. Don’t do it with a Jacoby Brissett. I would even say don’t do it with Kyler Murray. You’ve watched those guys play enough football to know what they are.

But someone like Drew Lock or Mac Jones? I’d consider them to be different. Both have been away from a starting role for a couple of seasons, which makes them closer to the Geno Smith move made in Seattle a few years back before flipping to Sam Darnold. Smith worked well for a couple of years, and then the Seahawks made a transition and hit the jackpot doing it. We’ve also seen veterans like Sam Darnold and Baker Mayfield resurface and seize their opportunities in recent years, too.

With college development where it is, more of those resurgences for quarterbacks allowed to develop in the NFL should come. 

This Steelers group feels like it has run its course

Pittsburgh’s roster is another part of why a veteran swing with unproven upside could be the move. This roster has a lot of work to do. The Steelers’ roster is currently tied for the third-oldest in the league. An overhaul is probably needed — but there are plenty of other picks other than a high-variance college quarterback that could help flip this roster around.

This group of Steelers players feels like it’s run its course. Yes, the rest of this season needs to play out and Pittsburgh is headed towards a playoff berth. Be honest, though — you watched the game against Cincinnati. What’s the ceiling? The Steelers have already started the process of assembling extra draft capital to build. Remember, they own two third-round picks thanks to moving Joey Porter Jr. This offseason, with Rodgers on the outs, more trades of veterans should probably follow to re-stack the deck and kickstart the youth movement. 

A veteran quarterback (with upside, not floor) on a reasonable deal, surrounded by a wave of young talent, is a different kind of bet than just targeting the biggest name left and doubling down on this nucleus again. The Steelers don’t need to force the 2027 quarterback class after saying goodbye to Rodgers. They just need to be patient enough to let the right swing play out.

Play A to Z Daily Games