3 Winners and 5 Losers: It turns out scoring 40 points means nothing if you have the Dallas Cowboys defense
The Dallas Cowboys defense allowed 584 yards of offense against the San Francisco 49ers offense. Here are this week’s winners and losers.
If I could I’d list every Dallas Cowboys defender except for Quinnen Williams and Joey Porter Jr. in the “loser” bucket of this article. It was not pretty for a defense that could not get off the field—largely because it couldn’t tackle a single soul on that field.
But that would be a little too much. So instead, here’s your usual dose of winners and losers after a Cowboys game, headlined by a couple of big names on the defensive side of things after a 46-40 loss in Arlington.
Loser: S Caleb Downs
It wasn’t a good outing for the first-round rookie, and rock bottom arrived in the third quarter, when 49ers RB Kaelon Black ran him over en route to a 25-yard touchdown rush. It wasn’t as much as a big car collision as much as it was Black going over a speedbump.
Downs’ tackling was an issue for the day, as he also missed a potential sack (that led to a 74-yard touchdown pass). He was also called for a defensive holding earlier in the game in coverage against George Kittle and allowed a big gain to Christian McCaffrey in coverage.
Loser: DC Christian Parker
I thought Parker’s game plan was solid early on, to be fair. The Cowboys were selling out to stop the run in the first half, as the 49ers averaged 3.8 yards per attempt. But the defense didn’t hold down the fort for long.
And while that’s largely on execution, the team has a roster-wide tackling problem. Some of it has to fall on the man in charge of the operation that was giving up 10 yards per play when the 49ers reached 46 points in the fourth quarter.
Winner: WR George Pickens
It wasn’t always pretty, but George Pickens was on play-making mode since early in the game. Sure, there were a couple of drops along the way, but the Cowboys WR1 who was widely discussed prior to the trade deadline scored a 35-yard touchdown and a 39-yard touchdown in the first half. He added another touchdown catch late in the game to bring up the total to three.
Loser: OLB Von Miller
The Cowboys needed a big game from Miller as he was asked to step up in the absence of Donovan Ezeiruaku and Malachi Lawrence. His impact was never felt in the game, with his most noteworthy moment coming in coverage versus Christian McCaffrey when he gave up a 66-yard touchdown.
Winner: CB Joey Porter Jr.
It was another game of Joey Porter Jr. holding it down, and this time he played most of the game. Per Sumer Sports, he finished with no catches allowed in two targets, including a one-on-one situation on All-Pro TE George Kittle.
Loser: CB Cobie Durant
In five targets his way, Durant gave up four catches for 59 yards. Keenan Allen had the bulk of it in his first game as a 49er. With DaRon Bland exiting the game early, things weren’t much better with Durant.
Winner: DT Quinnen Williams
Williams continues to beef up his resume for the 2026 season, and it’s looking All-Pro good so far. This time, he had a big-time sack against Brock Purdy and was a consistent factor in pressure and versus the run.
Loser: HC Brian Schottenheimer
It wasn’t Schottenheimer’s worst game as a play caller. In fact, I’d argue it was one of his best as many execution problems reared their ugly head. However, he lands on the list because this was yet another example of his team getting dominated in the second half.
The Cowboys were in it at halftime, but the Niners exploded in the second. That is tough to ignore in a Schottenheimer vs. Shanahan matchup.

