Titans’ Amani Hooker trade already looks like a problem as Jaguars expose Robert Saleh’s defense in post-bye déjà vu
Josh Cameron was wide open for a fourth-quarter touchdown, and my mind went straight to the second-round pick Tennessee got for Amani Hooker. That pick had better be worth it.
The Tennessee Titans came out of their bye week and handed the Jacksonville Jaguars 40 points. Instantly, one word jumped in my mind after the 40-23 final score sending the Titans to 1-8 on the season: déjà vu.
We watched this exact post-bye movie a year ago. A defense gets traded down to the studs, the backups get exposed, and fans are left trying to figure out what a young quarterback’s performance actually means when the other side of the ball can’t get a stop.
To be (slightly) fair to the Titans defense, I won’t even count that last Jaguars touchdown against them. The offense put them in a bad spot with a terrible 4-and-out turnover on downs, and Bhayshul Tuten busted through to turn a 33-point day into a 40-burger. Even then, that’s WAY too many points. It’s been great offenses lately (against Cincinnati and these Jaguars), but Tennessee is still giving up too much, too often.
The Amani Hooker trade showed up on the scoreboard
When Josh Cameron scored his fourth quarter touchdown, extending the Jags lead to 30-16, completely by himself, my immediate thought was simple: that second-round pick for Amani Hooker better be worth it.
That’s exactly the situation Hooker would have been on the field for.
Tony Adams was dealing with a potential concussion, which put Terrell Burgess in the mix. Between Burgess and corner Josh Williams, nobody was near Cameron.
That’s why I was against trading away Hooker. He was under contract for two more years, and now Titans general manager Mike Borgonzi has the 63rd overall pick from the Buffalo Bills. That’s good draft capital. But can a second-round pick do what Hooker did over the first half of this season? And how long does it take that player to get there?
Is that buying more time for Borgonzi? Maybe it’s a play to extend his job security. I don’t know, but you have to ask that question.
Sure, moving Hooker takes his money off the books to be able to spend on other players over the next couple of years in free agency, too. I get that. But this game was a straight-up representation of what happens when you trade away Amani Hooker. I don’t think Cameron catches that touchdown uncontested if Hooker’s back there.
And that matters.
Josh Williams and the Titans’ cornerback problem
Then there’s Josh Williams.
Williams has zero ball skills. Zero. That was the knock on him in Kansas City, and it’s why the Chiefs put him on the bench last season. He mostly played special teams with only about a dozen defensive snaps, because he couldn’t make a play on the ball. He might be in good position, but it doesn’t matter. Cameron did what he did, and that’s exactly why the Chiefs sat Williams down in 2025.
I understand Borgonzi signed Williams to be backup outside depth at a certain price. It’s not Williams’ fault. But he’s not any good.
Cor’Dale Flott is what I’m calling a ‘slow-twitch corner’. I’ve never seen a cornerback move less explosively. Midway through the game, I was ready to put Notre Dame cornerback Leonard Moore in every Titans mock draft I do from here on out with the second overall pick. The back end of this defense is that bad, and Tennessee needs a safety, too.
Here’s the kicker. I LIKED Cameron in the draft. When we ran Titans mocks and asked where the receiver drop-off was if Tennessee didn’t take Carnell Tate, I frequently landed on Cameron in the fifth or sixth round. Watching him go over the top of this secondary was a strange way to be proven right.
Cam Ward is better, which makes the defense harder to ignore
This post-bye stretch may be more entertaining than last year’s, because Cam Ward is way better right now than he was a year ago. The offense as a whole is much better too.
Ward was pretty good against Jacksonville. Yes, he threw an interception. Travis Hunter made a really good play, Elic Ayomanor has to come back to the football and fight for it, and Ward should have seen the front-side opportunities that were there. But I think he learned from it, and you saw that when he scampered 26 yards down the sideline in the third quarter.
A year ago, I just wanted to watch Cam Ward play. Now he’s giving me a reason to want to see him play with the game on the line. His own defense keeps making those chances harder to come by. Last year, that was after the Titans traded away Dre’Mont Jones and Roger McCreary. Now Tennessee has traded away two of the biggest playmakers on the defense, in Hooker and Jeffery Simmons. The depth behind them is a walk off a cliff.
I care more now, because I want to see Ward in situations that matter. When the defense is allowing 490 yards per game over the last three, it’s hard to get a fair read on what he’s putting together.
Robert Saleh’s defense is getting smoked.

