Todd McShay mock draft has Titans fleecing Jets in a trade back from No. 2, checking 2 big boxes in 2027 NFL Draft
Todd McShay has the Jets paying a premium to move up for a quarterback. The Titans slide just two spots, address two major needs by No. 13, and still have Chicago’s first-round pick. I finished the round to see who was left at No. 28.
Todd McShay’s latest “flash” mock draft has the Tennessee Titans trading back from the 2nd pick with the New York Jets and landing a haul. Tennessee ends up with three first-round picks in the 2027 NFL Draft, and two of them fill major needs in the top 13.
The Todd McShay Show ran a flash mock last week covering the top 16 picks. McShay took the even-numbered picks, and co-host Steve Muench took the odd ones. Things got fun when McShay had the Jets trade up from 4th to 2nd overall to grab North Texas quarterback Drew Mestemaker.
The exercise assumes Cam Ward stays the quarterback in Nashville. So the Titans don’t need a passer, and they collect assets from a team that does.
The Titans’ trade back with the Jets is an overpay (in the best way)
The Los Angeles Chargers take Ohio State WR Jeremiah Smith 1st overall. Then the Jets move up for Mestemaker, and the Titans get the 4th pick, the 13th pick, and a 2028 third-round pick.
“I think you are the Jets,” McShay said. “You’ve been actually as an organization wisely stockpiling to get to this moment. You were kind of hoping that Arch Manning was going to have the year that everyone thought he could have, you were hoping that like this was this quarterback risk. There was one (QB) definitively.”
“If everything were the same today, you know my love for CJ Carr. I think it’s an interesting class, but I think if you’re looking for the player with the greatest upside, with the arm, the size, the straight line mobility, I think they move up to go get Drew Mestemaker, quarterback from Oklahoma State. Geno Smith’s 36 years old. That’s a bridge. We all know that they’ve made all these moves to get themselves in position to go get the quarterback they want. In this simulation, they move up to go get Mestemaker.”
The A to Z Sports mock draft simulator says that extra third-rounder is unnecessary. In fact, it says the 13th pick alone is too expensive for New York to give up just to move up two spots.
McShay explained why the team trading up might have to overpay anyway. If Smith goes 1st, the Titans are sitting at 2 with control over who gets the top quarterback, and that gives Tennessee room to game the system a little.
“Remember, only from (pick) four to two ahead of division rival Miami Dolphins, right? Certainly, you can ask the question, well, why wouldn’t you just wait till number two because there could be some, you know, back and forth (about Miami) of ‘can we, are we sure?’”
Stack that onto what the Titans already own. They have the Chicago Bears’ first-round pick from the Jeffery Simmons trade and the Buffalo Bills’ second-round pick from the Amani Hooker trade. Tennessee also holds Chicago’s 2028 first-rounder, so this deal would add a second third-round pick in 2028 too.
Draft capital ($$$) everywhere. GM Mike Borgonzi has to nail it.
Colin Simmons and Jordan Seaton fill Tennessee’s biggest needs
Muench sent Notre Dame QB CJ Carr to the Miami Dolphins at 3. Then McShay took Texas edge rusher Colin Simmons at 4 for the Titans. McShay called Simmons the better “overall football player” of the top two edge rushers, ahead of South Carolina’s Dylan Stewart.
Here’s how the rest of the board fell before Tennessee picked again:
– 5th: Philadelphia Eagles, CB Leonard Moore (Notre Dame)
– 6th: Jets, LB Chris Cole (Georgia)
– 7th: Washington Commanders, WR Charlie Becker (Indiana)
– 8th: Tampa Bay Buccaneers, EDGE Dylan Stewart (South Carolina)
– 9th: Arizona Cardinals, QB LaNorris Sellers (South Carolina)
– 10th: Atlanta Falcons, OT Zereoure Williams (Utah)
– 11th: Houston Texans, OT Trevor Goosby (Texas)
– 12th: New Orleans Saints, DT Xavier Gilliam (Tennessee)
Goosby is dealing with a patellar tendon injury, and A to Z’s Ryan Roberts broke down his situation and draft decision.
At 13, Muench took LSU left tackle Jordan Seaton for Tennessee. Seaton is arguably one of the top tackles in this class. Muench isn’t sold on the consistency of his tape this season, but he likes this range for him.
“I considered giving them a tackle at two,” Muench said. “I think left tackle for them is a significant issue. And if you’re going with Cam Ward at quarterback, what this trade allowed them to do is to get an edge and then get better value and fill a pressing need at offensive tackle.”
“And in this case, we’re going to get Jordan Seaton from LSU, who some people think will be a top five pick or a top 10 pick, depending on how high you are on him. I think the tape has been inconsistent enough to think that this is actually about where he should be right now. We’ll see if he moves upwards. He’s going to have the opportunity. He’s playing some good teams, but right now, I think he’s right around that 10 to 15 range.”
I’ve always believed you draft the tackle before you need a tackle. Dan Moore is under contract, and the Titans have plenty of cap space and cash to let him start. They can also move off that deal in 2027 if they need to.
That gives Seaton time to grow up a little. He played around 320 pounds at Colorado and dropped to just over 300 at LSU, and most draft analysts can see the missing anchor strength. He’s also a former five-star recruit who was a big-time transfer portal get for the Tigers.
Edge rusher and left tackle of the future? That checks two boxes.
I finished the first round for the Titans at 28
McShay’s mock wrapped with Clemson CB Ashton Hampton at 14, LSU WR Jackson Harris to the Las Vegas Raiders at 15, and Ole Miss QB Trinidad Chambliss to the Cleveland Browns at 16. That’s four quarterbacks in the top 16.
So I ran the rest of the first round through the A to Z simulator to find out what’s waiting at Chicago’s pick.
At 28, I had a decision to make. Mississippi State CB Kelley Jones (who I probably would have taken) went 27th to the Detroit Lions, one pick in front of me. Staring at me was LSU tight end Trey’Dez Green, a 6-foot-7 basketball-type field stretcher who scores touchdowns.
The rest of the board had Indiana WR Nick Marsh, Oregon DT Ahmari Washington, Notre Dame S Tay Johnson, Oklahoma DT David Stone, and Alabama DT Devin Tompkins.
With 34th overall coming right behind it, I didn’t like how the receiver room dropped off after Marsh. The next corner would have been a significant reach.
So I took Marsh. He’s 6-foot-3, a strong ball winner, the 4th receiver in this class, and the 22nd player on the A to Z board. That makes him the bigger version of Carnell Tate.
Is another first-round receiver a luxury? Yes, absolutely. But at 28, he was the best of all the options.
Green went 31st to Buffalo, and Washington went 32nd to the San Francisco 49ers. With the Chargers on the clock at 33, I still had Stone, Johnson, Tompkins, and safety Kingston Lopa staring back at me.
I feel REALLY good about landing a strong defensive lineman or safety at 34… and that’s before the Titans ever touch the Bills’ pick. Tompkins would have been my top choice at 34.

