Jeremiah Smith tops updated Heisman ladder after Week 11 in one of the weakest races college football has seen in years
An ankle injury shook up the Heisman Trophy race this week, and the contenders chasing the top spot are productive players who still leave plenty to be desired as voting gets closer.
Here’s my updated Heisman ladder after Week 11, and I’m not going to sugarcoat it. This is one of the weakest Heisman Trophy races I’ve ever seen.
Don’t get it twisted. This college football season has been one of the most entertaining in years, full of parity and chaos from week to week. But an entertaining season and an exciting Heisman race are two different things, and the race heading into Week 12 is not the second one. Voting is getting close, so here’s how I’d stack the top four right now.
Jeremiah Smith is still the best player in America
No. 1 is Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith. At this point, you just have to give him the award. Ohio State was back in the win column this weekend after back-to-back losses and Saturday’s win was fueled by another 10+ catch, 100+ yard game from the best player hands down in the sport.
The real shakeup to my rankings, however, happened last week. South Carolina quarterback LaNorris Sellers suffered an ankle injury and wasn’t able to play this weekend during the Gamecocks’ loss to unranked Arkansas. It is what it is. If I wanted to be delusional, I could spin that loss as proof of how much a player of his caliber means to his team. I’m not doing that today.
Smith, meanwhile, is going to continue to get force-fed the football every single week. He is the best player in America. And honestly, somebody has to win this thing. If nobody else steps up and forces the issue, it would almost feel wrong for anyone other than Smith to take home the Heisman.
The rest of the ladder doesn’t move me
My No. 2 entering Week 12 is Darian Mensah. The numbers keep coming. He found himself in a bit of a rock fight against Duke and still figured out a way to get the job done, and that counts for something. But Mensah is the definition of a really good quarterback on a good team. A Heisman winner? I wouldn’t go there.
My No. 3 is Nate Sheppard, who went up against Mensah in that game. He’s turned into a mini Christian McCaffrey, and he has been a blast to watch. His production has earned him a spot in this conversation, plain and simple.
And you may say, Tegan, you just knocked Mensah for being a quarterback with good stats, and now you’re putting another stat line on the list? Fair. The difference is that Sheppard is the reason you tune in to watch Duke. He makes the game fun to watch, and his production stands on its own instead of riding on the position he plays.
Rounding out the ladder at No. 4 is Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr. It’s the same case as Mensah: good player, good stats. But if we handed Carr the Heisman, it would feel like we were giving it to a guy simply because he plays quarterback on a really good team. That’s how I feel every time I watch him. He just doesn’t give off Heisman vibes to me.
Jeremiah Smith is the pick
Mensah and Carr sitting at Nos. 2 and 4 says more about this race than it does about either of them. Both are pretty good college quarterbacks. Neither has played like a guy who’s head and shoulders above the rest though.
Smith has. He is the most talented player in the sport, he gets the ball every week, and nobody behind him has made a case strong enough to take the trophy away. Unless someone plays their way into the award over the final stretch of the season, Jeremiah Smith is my Heisman winner, and I don’t see that changing anymore.

