Seattle Seahawks coach Mike Macdonald makes his quarterback stance clear, whether fans want to hear it or not
Mike Macdonald has made his preference clear as Seattle heads into their bye week, but Drew Lock’s impressive numbers raise serious questions about the decision.
Is Sam Darnold still the right quarterback for the Seattle Seahawks? Coach Mike Macdonald thinks so. I’m not so sure. Macdonald told Brock Huard and Mike Salk that the Seahawks are optimistic Darnold will get enough practice reps after the bye week to start on Nov. 29 against the San Francisco 49ers.
Macdonald made the pecking order clear. He said Drew Lock has been great, but Darnold is the quarterback. The numbers tell a different story.
Drew Lock has earned a real look
Darnold has been sidelined with a quadriceps strain and a cracked rib. He suffered both injuries during Seattle’s Week 8 game against the Chicago Bears on Monday Night Football.
Lock has started the past two games since then. The Seahawks beat the Arizona Cardinals at home and the Las Vegas Raiders on the road, and Lock looked solid in both.
Here’s the statistical comparison. Lock has played in four games for Seattle. He’s 4-0, completing 73% of his passes, with seven touchdown passes and zero interceptions.
Darnold has played in six games. He’s 2-4, completing 60% of his passes, with 10 touchdown passes and nine interceptions.
That isn’t a close comparison. One quarterback is protecting the football (for the most part) and winning. The other has nearly as many interceptions as touchdown passes and a losing record.
And look, the turnovers are nothing new to Sam Darnold. Even in the Seahawks’ Super Bowl campaign last season, he had 20 turnovers in the regular season which was near the top of the league. It’s just the risk that you take by playing him at quarterback, even if he is making some great throws.
Mike Tomlin explains the emotional side of the decision
Mike Tomlin offered some unique insight into what might be going through Macdonald’s head. On NBC’s Sunday Night Football countdown, Maria Taylor asked Tomlin what Seattle would do and should do at quarterback.
Tomlin pointed out that Macdonald and Darnold had a lot of success together last season, when they won a Super Bowl. In the wise words of Tomlin, that adds a lot to your “emotional bank account” as a head coach.
Tomlin said it’s hard to turn away from a guy you won a Super Bowl with just a year later. He also said he would stick with Darnold because of the success the two had together last season.
Look, I understand where Tomlin is coming from. He’s coached long enough to know that loyalty matters in a locker room, and he knows the human side of these decisions better than most. Benching the quarterback who just brought a title to Seattle is easier said than done.
Lock is the better quarterback for Seattle right now
With that being said, I think Lock is the best quarterback for the Seahawks if the goal is winning games this season. It’s undeniable that he’s playing better. From the quarterback position, he gives Seattle a better chance to win.
Last season’s Super Bowl doesn’t change what’s happening on the field now. Darnold’s turnovers have been a problem, and Lock has kept the offense clean while stacking wins. A team defending a title should start whoever gives it the best shot, and that’s Lock.
Now, I don’t expect Macdonald to make that switch, I expect to take him at his word. I would assume we see Sam Darnold under center at quarterback against the 49ers when the Seahawks return to play in a couple of weeks. Macdonald said as much, and Tomlin’s read on the emotional side backs it up.
I’ll tell you this much, though. If Seattle has to turn to Lock again at some point, it should know he’s ready to go. He’s shown he can play good football, and the Seahawks may need him again before this season is over.

