Patriots could explore 4 quarterback options after Drake Maye’s injury, and most come with a familiar coaching connection
New England has Tommy DeVito and a rookie behind its injured starter, and free agency and practice squads are the only routes left after the deadline.
The New England Patriots will be without quarterback Drake Maye for an extended period, potentially the rest of the season, after he suffered what’s believed to be a broken ankle. The timing complicates any plan to add help at the position because the trade deadline has already passed.
The Patriots still have Tommy DeVito and rookie Behren Morton on the 53-man roster. Even so, the front office could evaluate the market around the league and add depth. Free agency is one path, and signing a player off another team’s practice squad is the other.
Here are four options New England could consider.
QB Jimmy Garoppolo
Garoppolo is semi-retired after spending the past two seasons with the Los Angeles Rams, and he has an extensive history with offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels. The Patriots drafted him in 2014, and he stayed in New England through 2017 before reuniting with McDaniels on the Las Vegas Raiders in 2023. The first experience went much better than the second one.
Garoppolo is still an experienced quarterback with a solid track record. He has started 64 games and owns a 97.6 career passer rating. At 35, he hasn’t signed with anyone in 2026.
Because he is a free agent, the Patriots could sign him to the practice squad first and elevate him to the 53-man roster only if necessary. That flexibility is a positive.
QB Bailey Zappe
Zappe also started his career with the Patriots as a fourth-round pick in 2022. He never worked with McDaniels, though, because Bill Belichick drafted him while McDaniels was already with the Raiders.
Zappe has started nine games: eight for New England in 2022 and 2023, and one for the Cleveland Browns in 2024. He played well as a rookie, then regressed mightily, and he has 12 touchdown passes and 14 interceptions in his career. He’s spent time with the Kansas City Chiefs, Browns, and New York Jets before his release in September.
The process would mirror Garoppolo’s. Zappe is a free agent and could sign to the practice squad. He is probably not a starting option, but he would add depth at the position if the Patriots want it.
The practice squad route
The other two options are on practice squads elsewhere, which adds a complicating factor. To add a player from another team’s practice squad, New England would have to sign him directly to the 53-man roster, and he would have to stay there for at least three weeks. Both players carry some level of starting potential.
QB Will Levis
Levis is on the New York Jets’ practice squad. The Tennessee Titans drafted him in the second round in 2023, when Patriots head coach Mike Vrabel was there.
Levis started 21 games for Tennessee from 2023-24 before missing the entire 2025 season with a shoulder injury. He was a capable starter despite some bad mistakes, throwing 21 touchdown passes and 16 interceptions with an 82.7 passer rating. He also added 240 rushing yards and a rushing touchdown, which brings another element to the offense.
He has practiced with the Jets since September, even without a chance to play. His most recent NFL game came in 2024, and that could be a problem. Still, the Vrabel connection, his starting experience, and his potential as a former second-round pick make him a realistic option for the rest of the season.
QB Nick Mullens
Mullens never played for Vrabel or McDaniels, but he did spend some time with the Patriots offensive coordinator. The Raiders signed him in April 2022 and traded him to the Minnesota Vikings on Aug. 22, during training camp.
Mullens spent the first part of his career with the San Francisco 49ers, where he started 16 games under Kyle Shanahan and was passable. After leaving San Francisco, he started one game for the Browns in 2021 and three for the Vikings in 2023. In 38 career appearances and 20 starts, he has an 88.3 passer rating, which is viable, but he has thrown 31 interceptions against 34 touchdown passes.
He can read defenses and is probably better suited for a Shanahan-style scheme. But more than that, McDaniels liked him enough to sign him in Las Vegas four years ago. Mullens has been with the Jacksonville Jaguars since last year, and he landed on their practice squad after Jacksonville traded for Quinn Ewers ahead of the regular season.

