‘I know in that room’ – The biggest reason the CFP committee is giving for ranking Alabama so high will make Tennessee fans even more mad
The Tennessee Volunteers dropped one spot in the College Football Playoff rankings this week despite their road win over the Texas A&M Aggies.
Tennessee faced a ridiculous amount of adversity last week before (and during) playing Texas A&M on the road.
The Vols lost defensive lineman Tyree Weathersby to a torn ACL, left guard Nic Moore missed the game due to a medical issue, running back Daune Morris crashed his car and broke his leg a day before the game, travel was delayed due to nationwide flight ground (UT didn’t arrive in College Station until after midnight), starting quarterback George MacIntyre suffered a knee injury in the first half, and wide receiver Mike Matthews tore his ACL in the first half.
And Tennessee still beat Texas A&M 22-7 in College Station (the Aggies have the No. 20 scoring defense in college football).
The Vols’ reward for all of that was dropping one spot in the rankings to No. 9, while Alabama remained at No. 3 after their 15-point road win over Vanderbilt.
It makes absolutely no sense. It is a clear case of Bama bias (Texas, after all, should be the highest ranked two-loss SEC team…then it should be Tennessee then Alabama).
The biggest reason the committee is ranking Alabama so high is because they’re essentially NOT penalizing them for losing to Tennessee.
The committee is saying that Alabama lost to Tennessee because of the hangover effect after playing Georgia the week before.
“I know in that room that they’ve given Alabama, and Georgia for that matter, a little bit of the benefit of doubt for losing after a big game,” said ESPN’s Heather Dinich on Tuesday night after the rankings were revealed. “There was a hangover week that happened in college football and Alabama was part of that. But also, remember, South Carolina is still ranked. They’re No. 21 — even after doing a faceplant at Arkansas.”
This is the most ridiculous nonsense I’ve ever seen in the College Football Playoff era.
I mean, Tennessee played a hard-fought game against Texas where their starting quarterback was injured and then the Vols played and beat Auburn the next week. Do they get credit for beating the hangover effect? (And don’t forget, Auburn beat Georgia in Athens a couple of weeks later).
Or how about Tennessee lost on the road to South Carolina the week after beating Alabama. Where’s the hangover effect excuse for the Vols?
It’s the clearest case we’ve ever seen of Bama bias. It’s so bad that it seems like the whole sport is on Tennessee’s side, and that’s something that never ever happens.
Alabama at No. 3 isn’t just absurd, it delegitimizes the enter playoff.

