Committee just screamed four unspoken words to Tennessee with latest playoff ranking fiasco

The Vols are simply not going to get the benefit of the doubt, particularly when it comes to a comparison everyone is making.

Craig Smith — College Football & NFL Trending News Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Tennessee coach Josh Heupel during a Tennessee football game against Furman at Neyland Stadium in Knoxville, Tenn., on Sept. 5, 2026. Angelina Alcantar/ News Sentinel / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

The Tennessee Vols found out their latest College Football Playoff ranking on Tuesday night, as the third of five pre-selection Sunday rankings were released on ESPN.

The belief coming in from some pundits was that Alabama’s relative struggles against Vanderbilt in a 21-6 win in Nashville last Saturday, coupled with a number of their best wins all losing again, could be enough to see their ranking finally drop below Tennessee, who delivered a 26-10 beatdown of the Crimson Tide back on Oct. 17. After all, Indiana plummeted five spots on a bye week.

Not so fast, my friends. Tennessee fell from No. 8 to No. 9 despite the travel struggles they had getting to College Station last weekend before a 22-7 win over Texas A&M in which the Vols’ defense completely dominated the Aggies. Indiana leapt Tennessee.

And not only did the committee keep Alabama at No. 3, committee chairman Hunter Yurachek actually PRAISED the Tide’s performance and win over the hapless Commodores!

“Alabama went on the road,” Yurachek said. “Didn’t play their best, especially on the offensive side of the ball, but found a way to win twenty-one to six at Vanderbilt. And we’ve seen this college football season after a big win like Alabama had at LSU a team let down and lose those games. Credit to Alabama not playing their best in Nashville on Saturday but finding a way to win.”

This committee is, frankly, unserious people. Crediting Alabama for a win over a 4-6 Vanderbilt team is a continuation of the window dressing that we saw in previous weeks when Yurachek was praising the Crimson Tide’s win over Mississippi State, who now also sits at 4-6. Praising those wins in this circumstance is absolute buffoonery.

Playoff committee made an unspoken and undeniable statement about Alabama regarding Tennessee: We like them more

And that makes it clear why Alabama is getting preferential treatment and a leg up on Tennessee in the rankings, and it’s something that’s undeniable: they just like the Tide more.

Throw out the resumes. Forget the best wins (Tennessee holds the edge there) and the worst losses (Tennessee lost by three twice at the last second; Alabama got worked in a 16-point loss). They just think they’re better, even though the teams played on the field and Alabama was overmatched.

This committee is simply going to find whatever logic they can frantically try to grab onto in order to justify their position and what they want to happen. That’s all that one can reasonably gleam from such an unreasonable decision. Head to head has been honored almost everywhere in the rankings. And when it doesn’t in this case, they come up with more nonsense to justify it.

Tennessee now gets to face that Alabama “big win” from Nov. 7 in LSU on Saturday. And how convenient the Tigers fell out of the rankings at 6-4 (despite a host of other 6-4 SEC teams staying in the rankings at 21, 22, 24, and 25).

There’s nothing Tennessee can do except take care of their own business, and that almost certainly won’t be enough to right this situation. After all, even when the metrics and resume changes don’t result in a drop for the Vols’ chief rival, maybe it’s time to listen to what the committee is saying without speaking.

Play A to Z Daily Games