Notre Dame is built to win shootouts or slugfests in the College Football Playoff, and only 1 other contender can say the same

Every College Football Playoff contender eventually gets dragged into a game it doesn’t want to play. Which teams can actually adapt when that happens?

Add as preferred source on Google
Notre Dame head coach Marcus Freeman, left, and quarterback CJ Carr (13) celebrate after winning a NCAA football game 52-0 against Rice at Notre Dame Stadium on Saturday, Sept. 12, 2026, in South Bend.
Notre Dame head coach Marcus Freeman, left, and quarterback CJ Carr (13) celebrate after winning a NCAA football game 52-0 against Rice at Notre Dame Stadium on Saturday, Sept. 12, 2026, in South Bend.

The Notre Dame Fighting Irish have a quality that very few College Football Playoff contenders can claim heading into the final stretch of the season. With the latest CFP rankings now out, and the Fighting Irish sitting at No. 6, I want to make a case I brought up during our CFP rankings reaction show this week.

Of every team projected to be in the field right now, outside of Georgia, Notre Dame is the only one I feel good about in this specific way. It doesn’t matter whether an opponent turns the game into a shootout or a bloody, low-scoring fight. The Fighting Irish are equipped to win either one.

That matters more in December and January than most people want to admit.

Every contender eventually gets pressed

Here’s the thing about the College Football Playoff. Over a long enough stretch, every team runs into a game where it gets pushed into playing a style it doesn’t want to play. That happens to everybody.

Even in the NIL era, we are still talking about 18- to 23-year-olds. Volatility is very real. Players have off days, and some games a team just doesn’t have it for one reason or another. When that happens, the question becomes whether you can still find a way to win when the game script flips on you.

Take Tennessee. The Volunteers’ defense is awesome, and I’m not arguing otherwise. My co-host Austin Stanley pointed out on the show that Tennessee has allowed just 13 points over its last two games and zero second-half points in that span. My other co-host, Travis May, has even called it a national championship defense.

Still, there is going to be a game where Tennessee has to try to score with someone. If the Vols get pressed into a shootout, are they capable of winning that football game? I’m not positive they are.

Travis admitted that’s the one scenario that makes him nervous with Tennessee: an opponent hitting a couple of explosive plays early and forcing the Vols to play catch-up.

Austin offered a fair counter. Tennessee has been the team dictating to its opponents all season, putting them in games they don’t want to be in. The Vols also showed some resilience at South Carolina, digging out of a quick 14-0 hole.

The other side of the coin

The same problem exists in reverse. Think about whatever team you want that has a really good offense but not a great defense. Wake Forest has been a great offensive team this year. I know some people will dismiss that because the Demon Deacons play in the ACC, but the production has been there.

Does Wake Forest want to play a 23-20 game? I don’t think so. May noted that Miami is the only team that has really been able to drag Wake Forest into that kind of game. Stanley also raised a valid concern for a potential first-round road trip. The toughest environment Wake has played in this year was Louisville.

Alabama falls into a similar bucket. The Crimson Tide have been just okay defensively, which raises its own questions if a game turns into a rock fight.

I keep thinking back to Texas against Arizona State two seasons ago. Texas had a very good defense that year, but Arizona State, led by quarterback Sam Leavitt, nearly won that game. The Longhorns looked very uncomfortable down the stretch because Arizona State forced them to play a game they didn’t want to play.

Why Notre Dame can be a chameleon

That brings me back to Notre Dame. When the playoff arrives, I think two questions decide a lot of these games. Which team makes the other play the game it doesn’t want to play? And which team can become a chameleon and win on either side of that equation?

The Irish check that box, and a big reason why is quarterback CJ Carr. What he has become this year has been phenomenal. Travis made the point that even in the loss to BYU, Carr stayed calm and collected and kept making impressive throws. That kind of poise is exactly what lets an offense keep pace when a game turns into a track meet.

Pair that with a defense capable of grinding out a low-scoring win, and Notre Dame doesn’t have to rely on one script. Travis put it well on the show. He has almost no questions about the Irish’s ability to adjust to the style of whoever they face.

Georgia sits in the same category. Outside of whatever the Auburn game was, the Bulldogs have looked like a juggernaut again and are close to a touchdown favorite against the field.

If you ask me, though, Notre Dame is right there with them as the team best built to survive whatever a playoff opponent throws at it.

Play A to Z Daily Games