Notre Dame football’s College Football Playoff floor and ceiling come into focus after dropping behind Texas in latest rankings
Notre Dame football slipped behind Texas in the latest College Football Playoff Rankings. Just how high, or how low, could an 11-1 Fighting Irish team finish?
Notre Dame football dropped to No. 6 in the latest College Football Playoff Rankings, flipping spots with Texas. The Fighting Irish are still in strong shape to make the 12-team field. The bigger question now is where an 11-1 Notre Dame team ultimately lands in the CFP seeding.
That assumes Marcus Freeman’s team takes care of business against SMU and Syracuse to close the regular season. If you ask me, that is a safe assumption.
During our CFP Rankings reaction show, I asked Travis May, who spends more time with the College Football Playoff Predictor than anybody, to walk through the ceiling and the floor for the Irish.
Why the drop to No. 6 wasn’t a surprise
I was mentally prepared for the slide to No. 6, which is why I wasn’t all that angry when it happened. I was settled on the committee propping up Texas after its close win over LSU. Notre Dame only played a bad Boston College team, so it was always going to be easy for the committee to slide the Irish down a spot.
That said, Notre Dame still won that game 41-7. It wasn’t like the Irish struggled against an overmatched opponent the way another SEC team did this past week.
The bigger issue is that Notre Dame’s resume is what it is at this point. SMU looked like it could be a top-25 win on the horizon. After the Mustangs got dismantled by Wake Forest, that opportunity isn’t even close anymore. That was a tough blow for the Irish.
The worst-case scenario for an 11-1 Notre Dame
Travis laid out a realistic path where an 11-1 Notre Dame team ends up as the fifth seed. In that scenario, Georgia wins the SEC, Utah wins the Big 12, and UCLA wins the Big Ten. Alabama qualifies for the SEC Championship Game and loses to Georgia by a field goal.
From there, the committee could decide to put a three-loss Alabama ahead of an 11-1 Notre Dame team anyway. Travis noted that Texas could fill that same role in a similar situation. That is the outcome Irish fans should fear most, because it would mean Notre Dame doesn’t even get a first-round bye.
Austin Stanley ran his own hypothetical during the show. He had Georgia winning the SEC, an undefeated UCLA taking the Big Ten, an undefeated Utah winning the Big 12, and Miami winning out as the ACC champion. Even with all of that breaking against them, the lowest he could push Notre Dame was sixth.
The most likely outcome and the ceiling
The College Football Playoff Predictor views the middle outcome much more kindly. According to Travis, the most likely landing spot for an 11-1 Notre Dame team is around the third seed.
Utah and UCLA are the two teams that could still finish truly undefeated. I don’t believe both will get there, though Utah might. Even if one of them does, it is not going to jump Georgia. Travis described the Bulldogs as “basically a touchdown favorite against almost the entire field” at this point.
Because of that, Travis sees the realistic peak for the Irish as the No. 3 seed, with the middle sitting at three or four. Anything higher would be an outlier of all outlier situations.
The independent question
Travis believes the realistic floor is the fifth spot. Notre Dame’s strength of schedule sits around 40th, and the remaining slate is barely top 60. That number isn’t going to do much for the Irish.
The committee’s weighing of the rest of the resume is the interesting part, though. Notre Dame checks a lot of the boxes the committee is supposed to care about, including game control, average win probability throughout games, and strength of record. Travis did wonder whether the committee might punish the Irish anyway simply because they aren’t in a conference.
My mind is still settled on Notre Dame being in this field as long as it beats SMU and Syracuse. Anytime you move down even one spot, though, it’s natural to think about the worst possible outcome. If the Irish land in the top four, they get a bye and a clear path to make a strong push. We will see how the final weeks play out.

