‘I think the committee is really paying attention to that’ – ESPN’s Greg McElroy says the quiet part out loud about how the CFP committee is handling Tennessee
The Tennessee Volunteers dropped one spot in the College Football Playoff rankings this week despite their 22-7 road win over the Texas A&M Aggies.
Everyone in college football is trying to make sense of why Tennessee is ranked six spots below Alabama in this week’s College Football Playoff rankings despite the two teams having the same record and the Vols owning a 16-point win over the Crimson Tide.
It’s something that makes absolutely no sense, and no one has been able to come up with a logical reason for why Alabama is ranked No. 3 and Tennessee is No. 9 beyond some mysterious strength of schedule metrics that the College Football Playoff committee is using (which is wild because the two teams play six of the same SEC opponents this season, and the other two opponents are comparable: Georgia and Mississippi State for Bama and Texas and Arkansas for Tennessee).
ESPN’s Greg McElroy, a former Alabama quarterback, doesn’t quite understand it either.
McElroy, though, believes he knows why it’s happening. He says the committee simply doesn’t value defense the way it does offense, and it’s dinging the Vols for their defense-first approach.
“The problem with Tennessee right now is they are 39th in offensive efficiency,” said McElroy. “And I think that’s what the committee is paying attention to. I think the committee is really paying attention to that. And to make things even more challenging for Tennessee right now, their upcoming opponent this weekend is the LSU Tigers, and the LSU Tigers do not reside in the College Football Playoff Committee’s top 25.
“… There’s a gap there (between Tennessee and the “pod” that Alabama is in), clearly, according to the committee. I don’t necessarily agree with it because I do think this committee values offense more than they value defense. I also think there’s a possibility that the committee is taking into account losses, like we talked about earlier. Good losses. Well, I don’t ever subscribe to that ideology — a loss is a loss. … To me, this version of the committee, they are looking at Tennessee’s losses and they’re saying, ‘Alright, you lost No. 5 Texas. There’s nothing wrong with that. You also lost to No. 21 South Carolina.’ And I think the committee is penalizing Tennessee for that. I also think, like I said, that they are penalizing Tennessee for their offensive efficiency. I think it’s very unfortunate for Tennessee.”
If that’s the case, then fire this committee into the sun. They’ve lost the plot. The goal is to win each week. It’s not the committee’s place to judge how a team won, or how they might win in the future. Resumes are about what you’ve done, not what the committee thinks you’re going to do (I mean, they have no clue what’s going to happen in future games just like none of us have a clue).
Tennessee fans — and college football fans in general — deserve more transparency. The Vols are getting the shaft, and it could cost the program a home playoff game.

