Lions Prediction Lab: Both Lions and Buccaneers beat writers expect a much closer game than the records suggest and explain why

Buccaneers beat writer Evan Winter joins me to break down Tampa Bay’s struggling passing game, dangerous defense, and why we both expect Detroit to win a close one.

Add as preferred source on Google
Junfu Han-Imagn Images and Matt Marton-Imagn Images

The Detroit Lions are going for their sixth straight win Sunday when they take on the 3-6 Tampa Bay Buccaneers in Week 11. On paper, a lot of Lions fans are looking at this one as an easy win.

To get a better feel for this matchup, I linked up with our own Evan Winter, A to Z Sports’ Buccaneers beat writer for this week’s Prediction Lab. And this game might be a bit harder than it seems on the surface regarding the Bucs’ 3-6 record.

Where the Lions can win: The Bucs passing offense has been historically bad

Let’s start with the obvious. JP Acosta posted on X this week that the Bucs have the 11th-worst passing offense in NFL history and he’s not wrong by any measure.

The context behind the Buccaneers’ season helps paint the picture: Jalon Daniels, an undrafted rookie, started three games at quarterback. His lack of experience, along with the defenses he faced (outside the Cowboys), made it very hard to make plays through the air on a consistent basis.

But the problems go much deeper than that. Offensive coordinator Zac Robinson’s route concepts lack creativity and are easy for defenses to key in on. Baker Mayfield hasn’t been good for a calendar year, and he has been worse this season. In the Bears game, he threw two interceptions, including a pick-six to Jaylon Johnson on a throw to Cade Otton that Johnson was locked in on the entire time.

The receivers aren’t helping either. Chris Godwin averages 4.4 yards of separation per NextGenStats, which ranks among the top six qualified receivers in the league. Even so, he isn’t getting the ball much. After Godwin, no other Tampa Bay receiver ranks in the top-41 in average separation among qualified receivers.

There’s also the Mayfield situation to watch. He didn’t practice Wednesday and was in street clothes, but he did practice Thursday and reportedly looked fine according to beat writers in attendance. 

Where the Lions can get beat: Tampa Bay can still run the ball

Even if the passing game is a mess, the Bucs can still hurt you on the ground.

Bucky Irving has been playing well, and Kenny Gainwell has become a bigger part of the plan. He had 88 yards against the Panthers and followed that up with 25 carries for 140 yards against the Falcons. Sean Tucker can break off a big run as well. The offensive line is made up of maulers in the run game, and Robinson has done a good job of mixing up the different concepts, whether it be gap, zone, inside zone, duo, etc. to help keep defenses from keying in on a certain trend.

That sets up a strength-on-strength matchup. Over the last five weeks, Detroit is second in the NFL in fewest rushing yards allowed. Who’s first? Tampa Bay.

The defense is the real problem for Detroit

This is the part that should get Lions fans’ attention. The Bucs have a “championship caliber defense” and they rank from the top-5 to the top-10 in nearly every important metric against both the run and the pass.

Bowles has been on a roll since Week 5 in Dallas. Dak Prescott, Aaron Rodgers, Michael Penix Jr., Bryce Young, and Caleb Williams have all had trouble against this group. The secondary is healthy, led by Zyon McCollum who is playing like one of the best cornerbacks in the league. Jacob Parrish is also one of the best up-and-coming corners in the NFL, along with Tykee Smith at safety.

Then there are the familiar faces. Alex Anzalone had a rough start, but he has turned it around and now has four interceptions, tied for third in the NFL. Al-Quadin Muhammad has two sacks as a rotational pass rusher. EDGE Yaya Diaby, who has been dealing with a knee injury, practiced Wednesday and sounds like he will play.

Then guys like linebacker Josiah Trotter, defensive lineman A’Shawn Robinson, and EDGE David Walker have had their own significant contributions that have helped take the defense to an elite level.

So how do the Lions beat the Buccaneers defense? The answer is simple: Get Jahmyr Gibbs going. If this game comes down to Jared Goff alone, the Bucs will move him off his spot and throw off his rhythm. Goff can still win a game like that, but it’s not the path Detroit wants.

Final Predictions

Evan: I’m taking the Lions 19-17. Tampa Bay hasn’t beaten a good team yet, although every Bucs loss has come by one score. There’s also the fact the Bucs are coming off a bye, while Detroit just traveled to Miami and then Germany.

Mike: Dan Campbell said Tuesday morning that the Bucs record is not indicative of who they are, and I think that’s true.

Still, I’m going with the Lions. Even without Aidan Hutchinson, they have a solid defense and one of the best offenses in football. The Bucs have a very good defense and one of the worst offenses in the league. I’ll take the more balanced team, Lions 20-17.

Play A to Z Daily Games