Detroit Lions Mailbag: Life without Aidan Hutchinson, who can play edge? What free agent edge I’d go after vs. what Brad Holmes could do, and what’s the point of the media?
Who should Detroit call for edge help? Can Derrick Moore reach 10 sacks? And should Juice Scruggs keep the center job? Answering your questions before Tampa Bay.
The Detroit Lions are coming off a big win in Germany and now turn their attention to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers on Sunday. It’s the middle of a 12-day run that will tell us a lot about this team, and Lions fans have plenty of questions. We’re going to do our best to answer them. Let’s jump into it.
When will Devin White return, and where should he play?
Linebacker Devin White can’t come back until he’s eligible. That means he has to get through the minimum four games he wasn’t able to play. Lions head coach Dan Campbell keeps talking about White returning at some point, but I don’t know exactly when that happens. My guess is after Thanksgiving, and that’s purely a guess.
The bigger question is where he plays. I’d put him at the Sam linebacker spot. White can rush the passer, and he can work sideline to sideline. More importantly, that spot doesn’t ask him to do a whole lot in coverage, which is where he struggles the most. Keep him out of that situation as much as possible.
How much will Kerby Joseph play against the Buccaneers?
Then there’s safety Kerby Joseph, who the Lions activated Tuesday. Campbell said there will be a snap count, but he also said Detroit will be less conservative with Joseph than it was with Brian Branch. Here’s the thing. If being conservative with Branch meant letting him play 45 snaps in his first game back, then “less conservative” sounds like a lot of football. Branch was clearly on a snap count in the first half, and then the Lions decided he was fine and let him play.
With that in mind, I’d suspect Joseph plays nearly this entire game against the Buccaneers. The Lions seem optimistic about where his knee is, and Joseph seems optimistic, too. Let’s see if he gets through Sunday and go from there.
Are the Lions better equipped to survive without Aidan Hutchinson than they were in 2024?
D.J. Wonnum is a more than capable edge rusher, which Detroit didn’t really have last time. Alim McNeill is playing out of his mind. I’d be shocked if he’s not an All-Pro by the end of the season. Tyleik Williams is playing well, Skyler Gill-Howard can get after the quarterback, and Derrick Moore has four sacks in the last two games. I think you’ll see Moore come on even more.
Beyond that, Ahmed Hassanein has pass rush ability, Tyler Lacy is good at setting the edge against the run, and Levi Onwuzurike can kick outside. Eric O’Neill and Anthony Lucas both have pass rush ability, too. Tyrus Wheat gets joked about by fans, but he played fairly well last season.
The bad thing is that this goes from one of the best defensive lines in football to just a good one. Is that enough? We’ll see shades of the answer Sunday. Thanksgiving against the Bears is the real test, though.
Who would I sign to help replace Hutchinson, and who would Brad Holmes actually sign?
As for what I’d do as GM, I’d call Leonard Floyd. He’s 34 years old, but that’s simply who’s out there. Floyd had only 3.5 sacks last season, but he had 36 pressures in 15 games. You aren’t replacing Hutchinson, and I don’t know if you can even replace half of him with what’s available.
Azeez Ojulari makes the most sense to me. He’s on a practice squad in Las Vegas, he’s still 26, and he’s always had someone like Brian Burns, Kayvon Thibodeaux, or Maxx Crosby in front of him. Detroit would give him real opportunity.
Fans get caught up in names like Haason Reddick, Floyd, and Joey Bosa. You remember them when they were great and ignore what they’ve become. Even if Detroit signed one of them, I think Moore and Wonnum stay the starters.
Can any defensive tackles help on the edge?
Gill-Howard can absolutely kick out. Lacy is more of an edge setter than a pass rusher, but Onwuzurike can give you some rush. I also think you’ll see Trevor Nowaske, Derrick Barnes, and Malcolm Rodriguez get pass rush snaps, plus cornerback and safety blitzes. The Lions have a lot of ways to manufacture pressure.
When could Isiah Pacheco return, and would he have a role?
The latest on running back Isiah Pacheco is still a mid-to-late December return. At this point, I’d be shocked if we ever see Pacheco play for the Lions. Jahmyr Gibbs and Sione Vaki have a good thing going, and Jacob Saylors is doing his thing on returns. Why upset the apple cart?
You could carry four running backs. But from a coaching standpoint, Vaki has worked his tail off and produced. Putting a guy who just showed up ahead of him doesn’t make sense. Maybe Pacheco gets a few carries, but he won’t override Vaki.
When will D.J. Reed return?
I don’t know. Campbell said Tuesday the team would know more about whether he could play this week, but he didn’t sound optimistic. My guess is Reed returns against the Bears on Thanksgiving. Campbell speaks again at 3:30 p.m. ET Wednesday.
Will Baker Mayfield play against the Lions?
I have no specific info on Buccaneers QB Baker Mayfield beyond an injured leg. From what I understand, he’s closer to not playing than playing.
Should the Lions ride with Juice Scruggs at center for the rest of the season?
I think that’s already happening. Scruggs is playing well, and Cade Mays keeps getting hurt. Scruggs is a free agent after this season, and the Lions are kind of stuck with the Mays contract. If I’m the GM, I’m looking for a way out of that deal and a long-term contract for Scruggs.
Let’s see what Holmes does. If I were the GM of the Lions, Juice Scruggs would be my guy. He plays well, and he’s out there every week. Things do get a little better when Cade Mays plays, but Mays hasn’t had the availability to stay on the field. The best ability is availability, and Scruggs has it.
With that in mind, I’d look into trading Mays at the end of this offseason and sticking with Scruggs. That’s just where I’m at. I’m curious to hear what Lions fans think about it.
Would I take the over on 9.5 sacks for Derrick Moore?
I think 9.5 is possible. I’m just not sure I’d take the over. Moore has four sacks with eight games left, so getting past 10 would take quite a bit. He could realistically hit 10, and we’ll see what it looks like over the course of the next eight games. I wouldn’t go much higher than that, though.
I also don’t think he’s going to swoop in and win Rookie of the Year. Most of those voters have probably made up their minds at this point. You have to understand that he’s still a rookie. He’s looked great recently, but there are still things he needs to figure out, and we’re going to watch him try to figure them out.
What’s going on with Ahmed Hassanein’s inactivity?
I don’t. I wish I did. I’ve asked around, and no one seems to have an answer for me. I don’t know why the Lions won’t play Hassanein or what happened. I don’t know if there was some sort of incident behind the scenes.
At this point, Detroit is in a position where it kind of has to play him. We’ll see if the team does. Unfortunately, I don’t have any real insight beyond that.
What do media availability and press conferences provide that team announcements don’t?
It’s a fair question. The Lions can absolutely post their own injury updates, and they already do. Their social media accounts will tell you when they’re activating a player or sending someone to IR.
Here’s the thing, though. On Tuesday, Lions coach Dan Campbell said on 97.1 they plan to get Kerby Joseph going this week. At the press conference, he was asked what that might actually look like. That’s the difference. That’s where the media comes in.
Think about it this way. If the Lions put a player on IR, you’d want to know why. What kind of injury is it? How bad is it? Is it career-threatening? Can he play in four weeks? Can he come back this season, or are we talking about next year?
The same goes for Joseph. The team can say it’s activating him, but then we get to ask the follow-ups. How are you rolling him out? Is he going to start? Is he on a snap count, or is he playing the full game? How do you feel about where the knee is at? How does he feel about it? There are so many questions you’ll get answers to because we’re in the room asking them.
That’s what we’re there for. We’re the link between the team and you. Without that link, the team can come out and say it’s putting somebody on IR and leave it there. Then you’re left wondering what happened and whether that player is coming back at all.
It’s the same with staff changes. If the team fires somebody you liked, you’re going to want to know why. Take the Aubrey Pleasant firing, for example. No one really understood what was going on there. We were there to ask about it and get answers, and then there was an understanding as to why he was let go.
It may not seem like a lot, but we’re the guys getting you the information. Sometimes we can get more than the team originally let on, and other times we can’t. That’s part of the game. Eventually, though, you do find out more.
We’re there for a reason. It’s a good reason.

Detroit Lions News
