Notre Dame football gets an honest warning from a betting probability model before its Senior Day showdown with SMU

Notre Dame football hosts SMU in South Bend with a College Football Playoff spot within reach. What does the BTA Sports model expect from Saturday night?

Ryan Roberts — National College Football Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Oct 3, 2026; Chapel Hill, North Carolina, USA; Notre Dame Fighting Irish head coach Marcus Freeman reacts in the first quarter at Kenan Stadium.
Oct 3, 2026; Chapel Hill, North Carolina, USA; Notre Dame Fighting Irish head coach Marcus Freeman reacts in the first quarter at Kenan Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Bob Donnan-Imagn Images

Notre Dame football is two wins away from a spot in the College Football Playoff, and the first of those two wins has to come against the SMU Mustangs on Saturday night in South Bend. If the Fighting Irish win their last two games, they are in. The only question left would be where they land in the final ranking.

The game also doubles as Senior Day, which adds another layer to a matchup that already carries plenty of weight. With all of that on the line, I sat down with Austin Stanley and Nick Schell of BTA Sports, an A to Z Sports partner, to break down how their probability model views the Irish against SMU.

BTA Sports is a probability engine, not a sportsbook. The company does not take deposits. Instead, it provides probabilities on every possible market outcome in a given game.

What the BTA Sports model projects for Notre Dame vs. SMU

The BTA Sports model has Notre Dame scoring 38.5 points and SMU scoring 17.5 points. Its spread of 20.5 points lines up with the Vegas number, so the two are very consistent on how big of a favorite the Irish should be.

The only real difference comes on the game total. Vegas has it at 56.5 points, while BTA sits slightly lower at 55.5 points. That might look like a small gap, but it tells you something about how the model expects this game to unfold.

For what it’s worth, I predicted a 41-17 Notre Dame win before seeing these numbers. That is about as close to the model as you can get, so I hope they are right on this one.

Why the Irish defense is the story

Schell did not hesitate when asked about the matchup. He believes Notre Dame’s defense has the strongest case for suppressing SMU’s production, and he sees a wide talent gap between the two teams.

“They’re just hands down a way better team,” Schell said. “I think this game is probably going to be won on the defensive side of the ball first.”

From there, Schell expects the Notre Dame rushing attack to grind things out in a ground-and-pound style game. He even floated the idea that the Irish “may even score a touchdown on defense” because of how good that unit has been.

The defense-first outlook explains the lower game total. Schell noted that when the model leans on defense, “those games usually do go under.” A defensive score could change that math in a hurry, but the model is built around Notre Dame keeping SMU off the scoreboard.

The case for an outlier

Here’s the thing about this week. SMU is coming off an ugly performance against Wake Forest, trailing 42-0 at halftime. That game is fresh on everyone’s mind, and Notre Dame fans have been talking about it all week.

Schell was quick to caution that a lopsided result the week before does not guarantee anything.

“This isn’t gospel,” Schell explained. “There’s always going to be outliers. SMU might beat Notre Dame.”

Schell, a University of Pittsburgh alum, joked that his Panthers always seemed to beat Notre Dame when he attended and then lose the next week to just about anybody. He also pointed to human nature as a factor. After a team gets blown out, he said, opponents can start to assume they will win easily, and the game ends up tighter than expected.

“And then all of a sudden, you’re in a seven-point game in the fourth quarter,” said Schell.

He referenced Utah’s close win last week as an example of a game that did not follow the script, even though BTA had projected a much larger margin.

“There are going to be those outlier games. This may be one of them,” Schell said. “I could see it being a closer game.”

That is a fair warning for an Irish team that cannot afford a slip. Even so, the numbers still point toward a comfortable Notre Dame win built on the back of its defense.

What comes next for BTA Sports

BTA Sports is also preparing Version 2 of its app, which will present bet opportunity cards with probabilities and model-based insights directly to the user. The app is in TestFlight right now, and the company’s goal is to have it live Dec. 1, in time for conference championship games and the playoff push.

For Notre Dame, the focus is much simpler. Take care of SMU on Senior Day, and the Irish are one step closer to a deep postseason run. We will know where they stand by the end of Saturday night.

Play A to Z Daily Games