8 winners and 3 losers from Notre Dame football’s lackluster Senior Day victory over the SMU Mustangs

Notre Dame football moved to 10-1 with a Senior Day win over the SMU Mustangs. Who stood out, and what needs fixing before Syracuse?

Ryan Roberts — National College Football Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Nov 21, 2026; South Bend, Indiana, USA; Southern Methodist University Mustangs quarterback Kevin Jennings (7) passes as Notre Dame Fighting Irish defensive lineman Boubacar Traore (5) defends during the first half at Notre Dame Stadium.
Nov 21, 2026; South Bend, Indiana, USA; Southern Methodist University Mustangs quarterback Kevin Jennings (7) passes as Notre Dame Fighting Irish defensive lineman Boubacar Traore (5) defends during the first half at Notre Dame Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Michael Caterina-Imagn Images

Notre Dame football shook off a slow first half start and pulled away for a 24-3 victory over the SMU Mustangs on Senior Day in Notre Dame Stadium.

For head coach Marcus Freeman and the Fighting Irish, the win improves the record to 10-1 with College Football Playoff aspirations on the horizon. Only the regular-season finale against the Syracuse Orange remains next weekend.

An up-and-down performance always produces a few players who decide the game and a few who struggle or underwhelm. Saturday night had plenty of both. Rhett Lashlee’s program has been a good one over the last couple of years, but Notre Dame had the clear talent advantage in South Bend.

Here are the biggest winners and the Fighting Irish who had underwhelming outings.

The winners

Boubacar Traore

The 6-5, 250-pound senior defensive end continues to make his mark on this Notre Dame program. Traore finished with six total tackles, 2.5 tackles for loss, and a pass breakup. That box score doesn’t tell the full story of his impact on Saturday night. He has asserted himself as one of the best defensive end prospects in the 2027 NFL Draft class and has arguably been the team’s best defender this season.

Jordan Faison

The talented wideout delivered a tremendous senior night for the Fighting Irish offense. Faison hauled in seven receptions for 109 yards and a touchdown, continuing a strong senior season for the 5-10, 184-pound pass catcher. He began his career as a walk-on and stepped away from lacrosse this offseason to pursue his NFL dreams. That decision has paid off, to say the least. Faison remains the go-to guy for quarterback CJ Carr.

Jayden Sanders

Heading into the 2026 season, I thought Sanders would be a nice depth piece at outside corner and inside at nickel. He has become much more than that. Sanders was fantastic against SMU, snagging an outstanding interception in the second quarter and routinely blanketing the Mustangs’ wide receivers. The former Michigan transfer has become one of the most valuable members of this defense and secondary.

CJ Carr

Carr threw a bad second-half interception and was off at times early, but he still had a strong day. He completed 19-of-29 passes for 312 yards and a touchdown against one interception. That marks his third 300-yard passing game of the season. Even on an uneven night, the 6-2, 215-pound signal caller showed why he is one of the best in college football.

Charles Jagusah

What a sight it was to see the 6-7, 330-pound offensive lineman back on the field. Before the 2025 season, Jagusah was in an accident that led to a broken humerus. The long recovery process also included an infection and nerve issues. After a daunting road back, he got into the action against SMU as part of the field goal unit.

It wasn’t long ago that many wondered whether his Notre Dame career was over. Seeing him finally make it back onto the field in Notre Dame Stadium was a tremendous moment.

Joey O’Brien

O’Brien did have a bad missed tackle on an SMU tight end in the second half. Even so, he was mostly very good filling in for the injured Luke Talich (let’s pretend like the targeting never happened). The 6-5, 205-pound freshman finished with seven total tackles, a pass breakup, and half a tackle for loss. He keeps making flash plays whenever he gets increased snaps, and his future is bright.

Styles Prescod

Prescod filled in for starting left tackle Will Black, who suffered a concussion last week, and did a nice job. For the most part, you didn’t notice him in pass protection, which is always a good thing for an offensive lineman. He also delivered a couple of key blocks in the run game, especially in the second half. His outing makes you feel better about the depth on the offensive line.

Nolan James Jr.

It was a slow first half for James, but he finished with 15 carries for 98 yards and a touchdown. That included a 38-yard scamper early in the second half. He also added three receptions for 31 yards, showcasing his all-around profile. The 5-10, 215-pound back might not be flashy, but he is incredibly efficient and has solidified himself as the No. 1 running back.

“The losers”

The injury bug

The unfortunate part of the victory was the injuries. Talich left the game with a lower-body injury and was seen on the sideline on crutches and in a walking boot. There is no definite understanding of what the injury is. With how Talich has been playing, most will hope it isn’t a season-ending issue for the 6-4, 220-pound safety.

Wide receiver Jaden Greathouse also went down after a strong start that included a 62-yard reception. Greathouse has stayed healthy this season after injuries plagued him the last couple of years. The hope is that this is only a minor setback. Leonard Moore was also banged up, although he returned to the game. With only one regular-season game left, Notre Dame needs to be as healthy as possible.

First half run game script

Notre Dame really struggled to get the running game going in the first half. James was able to give them a jolt of energy in the second half, but it was a very slow start for Mike Denbrock’s offense on the ground. The starts on the ground have to be better.

First-half time management

The biggest coaching frustration came at the end of the second quarter. During a last-minute drive, Freeman opted to leave timeouts on the board and settled for a field goal. He doubled down in his halftime interview, describing it as a great sequence for Notre Dame.

Issues like that won’t get much attention on a postgame show after a victory. Once the Irish reach the postseason, though, that type of decision could come back to haunt them. It needs to be remedied, or at least discussed, as Notre Dame flips the page to Syracuse.

Play A to Z Daily Games