Who told Butch Jones he was fired? Arkansas State isn’t trying to hide their Hugh Freeze desire, per source

Butch Jones is out as the Arkansas State head coach, and Hugh Freeze is the heavy favorite to take over. That just made their relationship even more complicated.

Ryan Roberts — National College Football Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Sep 14, 2024; Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA; Arkansas State Red Wolves head coach Butch Jones reacts on the sideline during the second half against the Michigan Wolverines at Michigan Stadium.
Sep 14, 2024; Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA; Arkansas State Red Wolves head coach Butch Jones reacts on the sideline during the second half against the Michigan Wolverines at Michigan Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Rick Osentoski-Imagn Images

Former Ole Miss and Auburn coach Hugh Freeze is expected to become the next head coach at Arkansas State, according to multiple reports, including our sources, setting up a reunion between the former Ole Miss and Auburn coach and a program where he previously enjoyed considerable success.

From a football standpoint, there are reasons to understand the potential move. Freeze previously led the Red Wolves to a 10-win season and a Sun Belt championship in 2011. He knows the program, has experience coaching at the highest level of college football, and has demonstrated an ability to build productive offenses.

However, the circumstances surrounding Arkansas State’s decision to move on from Butch Jones make this situation particularly interesting. And quite honestly, the way the university reportedly handled Jones’ departure deserves just as much attention as the coaching search itself.

A current scout and former college personnel staffer provided some interesting insight into how the situation unfolded.

“Apparently Ark State fired Butch Jones because they’ve already got a backdoor in place with Hugh Freeze,” the scout explained. “Butch and Hugh have the same agent (Jimmy Sexton of CAA). School didn’t even tell Butch he was fired; his agent told him.”

If that account is accurate (and based on other conversations I have had, it is), Arkansas State may have already had its next head coach lined up while Jones was still in the picture. Even worse, the communication surrounding Jones’ departure was reportedly handled through his representation rather than directly by the university.

There is nothing inherently wrong with Arkansas State deciding it needs a coaching change. Programs have every right to pursue a different direction when they believe it is necessary. But there is a difference between making a difficult football decision and handling it professionally.

And this situation, at least based on what has been reported to me, doesn’t reflect particularly well on the university.

Hugh Freeze would be returning to familiar territory

For Freeze, Arkansas State represents an opportunity to get back into the head coaching profession at a place where he has already experienced considerable success.

His connection to the program dates back to 2010, when he served as the Red Wolves’ offensive coordinator. He was promoted to head coach for the 2011 season and immediately made an impact, leading Arkansas State to a 10-2 record, a Sun Belt championship and a No. 25 ranking in the final AP Poll.

That season helped open the door to the SEC.

Freeze was hired by Ole Miss in 2012 and quickly turned the Rebels into a competitive program. He went 39-25 during his five seasons in Oxford, including back-to-back 10-win campaigns in 2015 and 2016. Ole Miss also produced some of the biggest wins in program history during his tenure, including consecutive victories over Alabama.

His time in Oxford, however, was also surrounded by significant controversy. An NCAA investigation uncovered recruiting violations, including impermissible benefits and academic misconduct. Freeze eventually resigned in 2017 after university officials discovered personal misconduct involving calls to an escort service.

He resurfaced at Liberty in 2019, where he went 34-15 over four seasons. Freeze helped establish the Flames as a competitive independent program, including a 10-win campaign in 2020 and an appearance in the 2021 LendingTree Bowl.

That success earned him another opportunity in the SEC, this time at Auburn.

Unfortunately, the Auburn experience never came together. Freeze went 15-19 during his tenure, failed to reach seven wins in any season, and struggled to consistently develop the quarterback position. Auburn ultimately dismissed him in November 2025 following a loss to Kentucky.

There is no question Freeze has offensive coaching ability. His track record at Arkansas State, Ole Miss and Liberty demonstrates that. At the same time, his Auburn tenure showed that previous success and familiarity with a conference don’t automatically translate into another successful head coaching opportunity.

Now, Arkansas State appears to be a potential landing spot where he could rebuild his reputation.

There is certainly some familiarity working in his favor, and few candidates would have the same history with the program.

What Hugh Freeze could bring to Arkansas State

From a football perspective, I understand the appeal.

Freeze has already won at Arkansas State. He understands the recruiting landscape, knows what it takes to compete in the Sun Belt, and has experience building offenses capable of putting points on the board.

For a program that wants to compete for conference championships, there is a legitimate argument that Freeze offers a higher ceiling than Jones.

The question is whether he can recapture what made him successful earlier in his career.

He won’t have the same resources or recruiting advantages he had at Ole Miss and Auburn, but the expectations are also different at Arkansas State. The Sun Belt provides an opportunity to build a competitive program without having to navigate the weekly challenges of the SEC.

This would also be a chance for Freeze to return to a place where he has already established relationships and understands what it takes to win.

There are legitimate football reasons to like the potential move. Whether he can deliver on that potential is an entirely different conversation.

Butch Jones’ checkered coaching career

Butch Jones has built a lengthy coaching resume, with stops at several programs before eventually landing in the SEC. A Michigan native, Jones began his head coaching career at Central Michigan in 2007, where he went 27-13 over three seasons and won a pair of MAC championships. He then took over at Cincinnati, leading the Bearcats to a 23-14 record from 2010-2012, including a Big East championship in his final season.

Those accomplishments earned Jones the opportunity to take over Tennessee in December 2012. The expectations were significant. Tennessee was trying to restore its place among the SEC’s elite, and Jones was viewed as someone who could bring stability and recruiting momentum to a program that had struggled since Phillip Fulmer’s departure.

Jones’ tenure in Knoxville initially appeared to be moving in the right direction. After a 5-7 debut in 2013, Tennessee improved to 7-6 in 2014 before putting together consecutive nine-win seasons in 2015 and 2016. The Volunteers won three consecutive bowl games under Jones, and he brought considerable recruiting momentum to the program. Tennessee signed four consecutive top-15 recruiting classes, according to ESPN’s rankings, giving the program the talent necessary to compete in the SEC East.

However, there was a growing disconnect between recruiting success and on-field results. Despite having some talented rosters, Tennessee repeatedly struggled in big moments. The Volunteers were just 5-15 against AP-ranked opponents during his tenure and 3-12 against Alabama, Florida and Georgia.

Blown leads, questionable in-game decisions, and an inability to consistently get the most out of his roster became major frustrations for the Tennessee fan base. There was also a perception that Jones was more effective at selling his program on the recruiting trail than developing a winning product on Saturdays.

Jones’ public messaging also became a source of ridicule. His “Brick by Brick” mantra was initially intended to communicate patience and a long-term vision for rebuilding Tennessee.

Eventually, it became something fans used to mock the program’s lack of progress. The most infamous example came in November 2016, when Jones referred to his departing seniors as “Champions of Life” after Tennessee had fallen out of the SEC East championship race. What was seemingly intended as a message of appreciation quickly became a national punchline, particularly as the team’s results continued to disappoint. CBS News +1

The relationship between Jones and Tennessee ultimately deteriorated during the 2017 season. The Volunteers opened the year ranked No. 25 but endured a disastrous campaign, including a 41-0 home loss to Georgia and a 50-17 defeat at Missouri.

Tennessee fired Jones on November 12, 2017, with the team sitting at 4-6 and winless in SEC play. He finished his time in Knoxville with a 34-27 record, leaving behind a complicated legacy: he helped rebuild a struggling program and improve its recruiting profile, but ultimately failed to deliver the sustained success Tennessee expected.

The important distinction: Jones wasn’t an unsuccessful head coach at every stop. He had legitimate success at Central Michigan and Cincinnati, and his Tennessee teams had two nine-win seasons. But his time in Knoxville left a particularly complicated reputation, with many fans feeling that the program never reached the level its talent and recruiting suggested it should.

The Butch Jones situation deserves more attention

While the possibility of Freeze returning to Arkansas State will understandably dominate the headlines, I don’t think the way the university handled Jones should get lost in the excitement.

Jones was hired in December 2020 and spent six seasons in Jonesboro, compiling a 30-43 record. His tenure was far from perfect, but there were some legitimate accomplishments along the way.

The Red Wolves reached three consecutive bowl games from 2023-25 and won the 68 Ventures Bowl in 2024 and the Xbox Bowl in 2025. Considering the difficult transition Jones inherited when he arrived, there was at least some stability established during his time with the program.

Arkansas State ultimately decided that wasn’t enough. The Red Wolves were 4-6 in 2026, and the university apparently wanted a different direction.

That’s football. Coaches get fired, programs move on, and administrations make decisions based on what they believe gives them the best chance to win.

But the reported circumstances surrounding Jones’ dismissal are what make this situation uncomfortable.

According to the personnel source, Jones and Freeze share the same agent, Jimmy Sexton, and Jones was informed of his dismissal through that representation rather than directly by Arkansas State. The suggestion that the university already had a backchannel working toward Freeze’s potential arrival makes the entire situation look even worse.

There is also an unfortunate reality that Jones’ reputation probably makes this easier for Arkansas State. He isn’t necessarily someone who generates a tremendous amount of sympathy around the coaching profession. His public persona and the way his Tennessee tenure ended have made him a polarizing figure.

But that shouldn’t matter.

You can believe Butch Jones was the wrong head coach for Arkansas State and still believe he deserved to be treated with more respect.

Those two things aren’t mutually exclusive.

A coaching change that comes with plenty of baggage

There is plenty to discuss if Freeze ultimately gets the job. His history with Arkansas State, his offensive background, and his previous success in Jonesboro make him an intriguing candidate. There is a legitimate football argument for believing he could get the Red Wolves back into the Sun Belt championship conversation.

But the potential hire also comes with baggage, and not all of it has to do with Freeze’s own history.

The way Arkansas State reportedly handled Jones’ departure leaves a bad taste. If the university had already identified Freeze as its preferred candidate, it could have still handled the transition in a much more professional manner.

Instead, the reported sequence of events paints a picture of a coaching change that was orchestrated behind the scenes, with the outgoing head coach seemingly finding out about his own dismissal through his agent.

I understand the business side of college football. Relationships with agents matter, coaching searches are rarely as straightforward as they appear, and universities aren’t obligated to keep coaches they no longer believe in.

But basic professional courtesy shouldn’t be that difficult.

If Freeze does ultimately take over, Arkansas State will have its new head coach and an opportunity to move forward. Whether he can deliver on the field remains to be seen.

Still, the circumstances surrounding this potential hire are difficult to ignore. Between the histories and reputations of the two coaches involved, this is already shaping up to be one of the more unusual coaching changes of the cycle.

Arkansas State might end up getting the coach it wants. That doesn’t necessarily mean it handled the situation the right way.

Play A to Z Daily Games