Adam Schefter predicts an ‘auction’ for Titans’ No. 1 pick, and 4 trade packages show how competitive the haul could get

Adam Schefter believes the No. 1 pick could spark a bidding war if Tennessee lands it and sticks with Cam Ward. I tested four offers, and the highest bid wasn’t the one I’d take.

Austin Stanley — Co-Founder, Host, Content Creator
Add as preferred source on Google
Adam Schefter podcast Titans trade auction number one pick Drew Mestemaker Jets Dolphins Cardinals Browns
Adam Schefter (Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports) / Cam Ward (Trevor Ruszkowski-Imagn Images)

The Tennessee Titans hold the No. 1 overall pick in the 2027 NFL Draft as it sits today. At 1-8, with very few “winnable” games left on the schedule, Tennessee has a real shot to stay there.

The one game that jumps off the page is the Indianapolis Colts. Indy cut starting quarterback Daniel Jones on Friday after a loss to the Houston Texans on Thursday Night Football, and the Colts (3-8) are reeling. They don’t even own their first-round pick. That belongs to the New York Jets from the Sauce Gardner trade, back when the Colts did not expect to be this bad this fast. I expect Indy to lose out.

All of that sent me back to what ESPN’s Adam Schefter said on his podcast earlier this week. He walked through the current draft order, the teams at the top that likely don’t need a quarterback, and the chance for one of them to cash in on a group of teams that want Oklahoma State QB Drew Mestemaker.

Adam Schefter’s ‘auction’ prediction for the Titans’ No. 1 pick

Here is what Schefter said on his podcast:

“There is going to be an auction, I believe, for the number 1 pick for the right to go draft Drew Mestemaker, the Oklahoma State quarterback,” Schefter said. “Whether that’s the Jets trading up, whether that’s the Cardinals trading up… Dolphins, Jets, Cardinals, Browns, whoever. Somebody’s gonna want to trade up to number 1 if it’s Tennessee or the Chargers.”

“Tennessee, I believe, even at the 1 hole, would stick with Cam Ward. I think that there’s enough belief and conviction within that organization that they feel like right now— and there’s still 8 games to go for the Titans this season— they feel like they have a quarterback here.”

The word “auction” is what stood out to me the most, and we’re going to experiment with that in mind.

Why the Titans can like Cam Ward and still pick No. 1

The two most likely scenarios are the Titans rolling with Ward into 2027, or bringing in a veteran quarterback to compete with him. Diving back into the top of the quarterback market feels unlikely. Tennessee just did this a couple years ago… and now here it sits with the 1st pick again.

“Ward’s had 3 head coaches and 3 coordinators in under 2 years,” Schefter continued. “They want to give him some consistency. He started to come on the last 2 weeks, and he has what ails every quarterback this week coming up, a game against the Dallas Cowboys.”

So how does a team that believes in its quarterback end up picking first? Defense.

The Titans traded away their two best defensive players. Jeffery Simmons went to the Chicago Bears, which gives Tennessee two first-round picks in 2027 and two more in 2028. Amani Hooker, who was leading the NFL in interceptions, went to the Buffalo Bills to net a second-round pick.

The results have been ugly. Tennessee has given up almost 1,500 yards of offense in the last three games against the Cleveland Browns, Cincinnati Bengals, and Jacksonville Jaguars. That defense isn’t good enough to push the Titans outside the top three or four picks, and No. 1 is very much on the table.

Here’s the 2027 capital already in the bank:

– Titans first-round pick 

– Bears first-round pick (expected late first round) 

– Titans second-round pick (likely high)

– Bills second-round pick (expected late second round) 

– Titans third-round pick (likely high)

Simulating the bidding war for No. 1

I built this off the article I wrote this week about Todd McShay’s podcast. In McShay’s scenario, the Titans picked second after the Los Angeles Chargers took Ohio State’s Jeremiah Smith first, and he floated a trade with the Jets. I used that McShay package as the measuring stick, plus the other three teams Schefter mentioned: the Jets, Cardinals, Dolphins, and Browns.

Then I went to the A to Z Sports NFL Playoff Predictor, which simulates the season 10,000 times, and ran it until Tennessee landed at No. 1. That was the only requirement. Here’s the top 10 it spit out:

1. Titans 

2. Dolphins 

3. Jets (via Colts) 

4. Cardinals 

5. Philadelphia Eagles 

6. Jets 

7. Chargers 

8. Tampa Bay Buccaneers 

9. New Orleans Saints 

10. Baltimore Ravens

New York also owns the Cowboys’ pick, which landed at 14th. That gives the Jets three first-rounders (3, 6, and 14). Cleveland has its own pick and the Rams’ pick at 18th and 19th.

These packages are EXPENSIVE (since McShay started the auction bidding). All point values come from the A to Z Sports Draft Simulator.

Arizona Cardinals: 4,287 points

The Titans send No. 1 to Arizona for No. 4, No. 36, No. 48, and a 2028 fourth-round pick. 

This is the priciest offer by a whopping four points. Tennessee drops three spots and adds two more second-rounders.

New York Jets: 4,283 points (the McShay trade)

The Titans send No. 1 to New York for No. 3 (the Colts’ pick), No. 14 (the Cowboys’ pick), and a 2028 third-round pick. 

Technically, the Jets don’t give up a single first-rounder of their own. Tennessee would walk away with three first-round picks in 2027 (3, 14, and 28) and six picks in the top three rounds.

Miami Dolphins: 4,174 points

The Titans send No. 1 to Miami for No. 2, No. 34, and 2028 third- and fourth-round picks.

It’s the cheapest package, and Tennessee only slides back one spot. I tried to manufacture another 100 points in the simulator on the fly… let’s just say that didn’t go anywhere.

Cleveland Browns: 4,244 points

The Titans send No. 1 to Cleveland for No. 18, No. 19, No. 83, and a 2028 first-round pick. 

It isn’t the biggest offer, but it’s the most fascinating one. The other three keep Tennessee in the top four, while this one drops the Titans all the way to 18th.

The payoff? Six first-round picks across 2027 and 2028. That’s 18, 19, and 28 next spring, plus their own, the Bears’, and the Browns’ picks the following year.

Every one of these packages would be a tremendous haul for a team that already believes it has its quarterback.

So which offer should the Titans take, and how do they decide?

Why the Jets are the best-positioned bidder

The Dolphins and Jets both play in the AFC East, and both need a quarterback. To me, the Jets are in the best spot because they don’t have to give up their own draft capital to do this.

New York has built its organization to handle this exact situation. The Jets could send the Colts’ and Cowboys’ first-round picks, plus maybe their own 2028 third-rounder, to move up to No. 1. They have young talent around them. That deal is realistic.

The bigger question for Tennessee is what it does with the extra picks. The Titans have a desperate need on defense at edge rusher and cornerback.

I love Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith. If the Titans want to stay put and take Smith at No. 1, I’m completely on board. But this is an opportunity to collect enough draft capital to reset the entire defense and a few offensive spots.

The Marcus Mariota blueprint

This feels a lot like Marcus Mariota heading into the 2019 season. Tennessee had a playoff roster, and Mariota was going to sink or swim.

He sank. However, the Titans had Ryan Tannehill ready to step in, and Tannehill took them to the playoffs three straight years.

If Borgonzi can pull off a trade that resets the roster around Cam Ward, the 2027 season becomes Ward’s sink-or-swim year. Either he flourishes and the Titans are set for a long time, or they figure out who comes next with a roster already built to win.

Smith could be part of that build. So could Texas edge rusher Collin Simmons, Notre Dame cornerback Leonard Moore (who is a freaking stud), or South Carolina edge rusher Dylan Stewart. I’d rank them Smith, Simmons, Moore, and Stewart, which is roughly how they line up on the big board.

Assuming the team trading up actually takes Mestemaker, staying in the top 4 guarantees Tennessee one of those four players.

How each top-4 trade back plays out

Jets at No. 3: What does Miami do at No. 2? The Dolphins could take Smith and bring him home after watching Ohio State pull him away from the Hurricanes. Then the Titans take Simmons at No. 3. If Miami goes quarterback instead, Smith could be sitting right there at No. 3.

Cardinals at No. 4: Tennessee probably has to accept that Smith is gone. The Jets have more picks behind the Titans, and the Philadelphia Eagles likely aren’t taking a quarterback at No. 5. So New York could take Smith at No. 3 and grab a quarterback with its second first-rounder. Tennessee gets whoever is left among Simmons, Moore, and Stewart.

Dolphins at No. 2: This is the smallest move. Miami jumps up for Mestemaker, and the Titans can take Smith one spot later. Or they could shop No. 2 to the Jets, Cardinals, and Browns again for the second quarterback.

That would be VERY greedy and pretty wild. Trading back from No. 1 to No. 2, then again to No. 3 or No. 4, and still landing Smith, Simmons, Moore, or Stewart? That would be a heck of a heist for Borgonzi.

The Browns trade is the riskiest swing

Enter the Browns. I don’t think this is necessarily the best option for Tennessee. Three first-round picks at 18, 19, and 28 is a goofy spot to be in. (If you can’t tell… I really like the idea of Devan Thompkins across this Robert Saleh defensive front).

But remember the last time the Titans held the 1st pick before Ward. In 2016, they traded back with the Rams to No. 15, then moved up to No. 8 to take Jack Conklin as their right tackle.

Picture a Browns package of the 18th pick, the 19th pick, the 83rd pick, and a 2028 first-rounder. Tennessee could wait to see whether Stewart, Simmons, or Moore slips. It could also climb back into the back half of the top 10 for the draft’s second-best corner, Georgia’s Ellis Robinson IV.

The capital opens other doors, too. Clemson cornerback Ashan Hampton fits a team need, and defensive tackle Xavier Gilliam is an explosive interior presence somewhere in the first half of round one.

Of course, that path requires playing the board more aggressively than any of the others. That’s exactly why I want to see how it plays out.

I’d take the Jets offer. Arizona wins on the chart by four points, Miami gives me the cleanest shot at Jeremiah Smith, and Cleveland gives me another first next year.

But the Jets deal keeps me at No. 3 and gives me three first-round picks in this draft. I’m still in range for one of my favorite players, and I get two more chances on Day 1 to build the roster around Cam Ward.

That’s what I’d want out of the auction.

Play A to Z Daily Games