Why the Titans’ 50% odds at the No. 1 pick feel far too high, and the 4-team race that likely takes it away in the 2026 NFL Draft
The Titans sit atop the draft order after the Chargers’ win, and A to Z Sports’ simulator calls their odds of staying there a coin flip. I’m taking the field. Here’s why:
The Tennessee Titans are on the clock if the season ended today.
After the Los Angeles Chargers won this past Monday night, Tennessee jumped to the No. 1 spot in the 2027 NFL Draft order. The A to Z Sports NFL Playoff Predictor (which also works in reverse for the draft order) gives the Titans a 50% chance to hold the 1st pick when the regular season ends. That number comes from 10,000 simulated seasons, and it’s by far the highest of any team in the model.
Let me be clear: the Titans can absolutely finish with the top pick. They’re holding it in the middle of November, they’re squarely in the biggest loser race! But I don’t see this as a coin flip at all. If you gave me the Titans or the field, I’m taking the field. My gut puts Tennessee closer to half those good of odds, and I’d still bet against it happening.
The Titans’ offense is working against the top pick
For starters, Tennessee’s offense has started scoring enough to win games. Consider this: from Week 1 through the early games this past Sunday, roughly the first 10 weeks, teams that scored at least 23 points went 114-42, which is a win rate of roughly 72%. The Titans have scored at least 23 points in each of their past four games and are 1-3 in them.
That matters because the top pick usually goes to a three-win team. Sometimes it’s a two-win team, like last year. A one-win team is a real outlier, and a winless team is a historical one. So if you’re rooting for the 1st pick, Tennessee’s margin for “error” is one win, maybe two.
The question comes down to this: is the past month of offensive progress an aberration that comes crashing back down, or does Tennessee win its way out of the top spot? Statistically speaking, a team scoring like this doesn’t keep losing.
I understand that our model bakes in the schedule, the defense hamstringing the offense, and how many other terrible teams are in the mix. I just don’t think 50% reflects reality.
Regression, bad luck, and a schedule that isn’t death row
The Titans’ defense has been historically bad over the past three games, and nobody is arguing it’s about to get good all of a sudden.
The odds of maintaining some of the worst defensive marks in franchise history are extremely low. It’s hard to be that bad for a sustained stretch, which is why teams don’t do it. If the defense stops being historically porous, this offense keeps Tennessee in games and steals a couple down the stretch.
I say this every year because the Titans unfortunately keep finding themselves in this conversation: getting the 1st pick doesn’t just require being a bad team. It requires being a bad team and extraordinarily unlucky. Almost every No. 1 pick needs both.
The remaining schedule isn’t a cakewalk, but it’s hardly death row. I only see two games I’d bet heavily against them in today: the Jaguars and the Lions. The Cowboys, Commanders, Colts, and Raiders are all winnable, and I’d throw the Steelers in there too considering our recent measuring stick for both against the Bengals.
When I apply the same standard to the other contenders, they have way more “unwinnable” games than the Titans do.
Who else is in the race for the No. 1 pick?
As I see it, this is a four-and-a-half team race. The Dolphins, Titans, Cardinals, and Chargers are in it, and the Colts have one foot in (that pick belongs to the Jets, in case you forgot). Indianapolis just picked up its third win and basically needs to lose out to stay involved, which I’m not expecting.
The predictor gives Miami a 23% shot at the top pick, the Chargers 12%, the Jets’ own pick 7%, and the Colts’ pick 1%. The Dolphins are a barren roster by design, and Arizona sits at three wins with a very real chance to lose out given recent injuries. Los Angeles just won their first game, but it also has more winnable games left.
When Austin and I played out the rest of the season game by game on the A to Z Sports Morning Show, I gave Tennessee wins over Dallas and Indianapolis. The Titans finished 3-14 and still landed at No. 2. Miami picked first, the Colts’ pick (owned by New York) went third, and the Chargers fell to sixth.
The bottom line on the Titans’ draft position
The overall picture still favors Tennessee picking near the top. Per the predictor, the Titans have a 50% chance at No. 1, 23% at No. 2, and 11% at No. 3.
The top three feels likely. The 1st pick is a different story. I won’t rule it out, but between an offense that keeps putting up points and a defense that’s unlikely to stay this historically bad forever, I’m taking the field.

