The Alabama Crimson Tide‘s win over the Kentucky Wildcats on Saturday was a game defined by its halves. Alabama’s defense kept the team afloat through a dismal opening 30 minutes before the offense finally found its footing after the break. The Crimson Tide pulled away, but the first-half struggles exposed issues that won’t go away against better competition in the SEC.

View this post on Instagram

Winners: Alabama’s defense sets the tone

The defense was the clear star of this game. All 11 starters and the rotational players who cycled in for Alabama delivered under defensive coordinator Kane Wommack’s direction.

Luke Metz deserves top billing. With the offense sputtering and Kentucky dictating the tempo, Metz intercepted Kenny Minchey and took it to the house for a pick-six. That touchdown kept Alabama in the game during a first half where the offense contributed zero points.

The two big-time transfer portal additions also showed up in a major way. Devan Thompkins registered two sacks, including a strip sack that flipped the momentum and helped the Crimson Tide claw back into the game. He looked electric. Caleb Woodson, playing inside linebacker, flashed his closing speed early when he sacked Minchey, and then Wommack dialed up a blitz that sent Woodson off the edge for another sack. Both players have been tremendous transfer portal additions through these first 2 weeks.

Connor Talty rounds out the winners list. For everything the kicker went through last season, he kept Alabama in the game during the first half with his field goals. The offense put up no points before the break. All the Crimson Tide had was the Metz pick-six and Talty’s leg. He had a tremendous game.

Losers: Offensive line, run game, and play-calling need answers

Before getting into the losers, a caveat: most of these issues stem from the first half and were corrected after halftime. But that doesn’t mean this is a sustainable product for Alabama. Kentucky put up a good fight and looked well-coached, but the Wildcats are starting anew. Alabama cannot go out and play a first half like that against the Georgia Bulldogs, the Tennessee Volunteers, or anybody of real substance in the SEC.

The offensive line generated very little push in the first half. The right side struggled with following the loss of starting right guard Michael Carroll. The unit needs to create displacement at the first and second levels, plain and simple. To Alabama’s credit, the line cut out the gimmicks in the second half, abandoned the end-arounds and jet sweeps, put a hat on a hat, and bludgeoned Kentucky. But 5 total rushing yards in the first half cannot happen, especially in a quarterback’s first start on the road in the SEC against a team the Crimson Tide should dominate at the point of attack.

Whether it’s Daniel Hill, EJ Crowell, or Trae’shawn Brown, the coaching staff has to figure out which running back is hot and ride him. Alabama did correct course. Hill had a big-time scamper down the right sideline that should have been a touchdown, and Crowell found the end zone a few plays later. The fixes came, but these first-half mistakes simply cannot persist.

A lot of the early issues traced back to offensive coordinator Ryan Grubb’s play-calling. Some of the gimmicky calls, particularly on the goal line and in short-yardage situations, were head-scratching. The truth is, this is the Alabama Crimson Tide playing SEC football. Line up, beat guys at the point of attack, create vertical displacement, and go win the game. To Grubb’s credit, the second half reflected more of that philosophy.

Keelon Russell’s 2-half transformation

Keelon Russell’s first half was abysmal. There’s no way around it. He looked like a quarterback seeing ghosts. Three turnovers before the break: a bad interception, a fumble, then another bad pick. He looked nothing like the player Alabama saw in Week 1.

Then came the second half. Russell threw a touchdown pass to Rico Scott, his first as the Crimson Tide’s quarterback. He looked calmer, more poised. He broke out on a big-time run and chose to get out of bounds instead of absorbing an unnecessary hit like he did last week. His progressions looked sharper.

But the bottom line is this: Alabama cannot play LSU, cannot face Georgia, cannot play the October and November gauntlet ahead and expect to win if the quarterback turns the ball over three times in the first half. These are learning moments for a young signal-caller, and the second-half response was encouraging.

The Crimson Tide trailed at halftime on the road, a situation where Kalen DeBoer was 0-7 all time when losing at the break. Alabama changed that narrative with a strong second-half response. The question now is whether these corrections become the standard or whether the first-half version of this team resurfaces when the competition level rises.